University College Dublin, School of Medicine, Dublin, Ireland.
National Gender Service, St Columcille's Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
J Nurs Scholarsh. 2024 Jan;56(1):60-75. doi: 10.1111/jnu.12907. Epub 2023 May 16.
The purpose of this study was to identify the common factors that help and hinder transgender and nonbinary youth accessing gender-specific health care in Ireland and to identify how these factors may be perceived differently by young people seeking gender-affirming care, their parents, and health-care providers.
Qualitative investigation utilizing framework analysis (FA).
In-depth one-one interviews were conducted with transgender and nonbinary youth (n = 10), parents of youth (n = 10), and gender-specific health-care providers (n = 10). Maximum variation and snowball sampling were used to recruit participants across Ireland. An interview guide codesigned with an expert panel of gender-diverse youth was utilized. Interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim. FA was used to code the data and identify key issues and recommendations.
Four themes were derived: (1) "Needing bricks to build" (structural factors); (2) "Enduring and convincing" (diagnostic factors); (3) "Being me, hiding me"; (personal factors); and (4) "It takes a tribe" (interpersonal factors). Each stakeholder group perceived different factors as help or hindrance in accessing care with varying intensities.
Paramount to the future of gender services in Ireland is the investment of resources for children and young adults. Assessment is likely to remain a component of gender care, but youth recommend distinct revisions to the assessment process. Additional research would be useful in exploring the intersection of neurodiversity and gender as it pertains to health-care navigation. Family and peer support is a strong protective factor and enabler of health-care access among youth.
Access to gender-specific health care remains difficult for transgender and non-binary youth. An understanding of the complexity of this healthcare navigation by healthcare professionals may help to mitigate future negative experiences. This study explores some of the clinical considerations that arise for this population from provider perspectives while elucidating the experiences of youth and parents attempting to access care. Further research is needed on longitudinal outcomes following medical and surgical interventions for transgender youth, including nonbinary identities.
本研究的目的是确定帮助和阻碍爱尔兰跨性别和非二元青年获得性别特定医疗保健的共同因素,并确定这些因素如何被寻求性别肯定护理的年轻人、他们的父母和医疗保健提供者以不同的方式感知。
利用框架分析(FA)进行定性研究。
对 10 名跨性别和非二元青年(n=10)、青年的父母(n=10)和性别特定医疗保健提供者(n=10)进行深入的一对一访谈。利用爱尔兰各地的最大变异和滚雪球抽样来招募参与者。访谈指南是与性别多样化青年的专家小组共同设计的。访谈进行了录音并逐字记录。FA 用于对数据进行编码,以确定关键问题和建议。
得出了四个主题:(1)“需要砖头来建造”(结构性因素);(2)“持久而令人信服”(诊断因素);(3)“做我自己,隐藏自己”(个人因素);和(4)“需要一个团队”(人际因素)。每个利益相关者群体都认为不同的因素对获得护理有帮助或有阻碍,但强度不同。
爱尔兰未来性别服务的关键是为儿童和年轻人投入资源。评估可能仍然是性别护理的一个组成部分,但年轻人建议对评估过程进行明显的修改。进一步的研究将有助于探索神经多样性和性别在医疗保健导航方面的交集。家庭和同伴支持是年轻人获得医疗保健的有力保护因素和促进因素。
跨性别和非二元青年获得性别特定医疗保健仍然困难。医疗保健专业人员对这种医疗保健导航的复杂性的理解可能有助于减轻未来的负面体验。本研究从提供者的角度探讨了这一人群的一些临床注意事项,同时阐明了试图获得护理的年轻人和父母的经历。需要进一步研究跨性别青年(包括非二元身份)接受医疗和手术干预后的长期结果。