Faculty of Geo-Information Science and Earth Observation, ITC, University of Twente, Enschede, the Netherlands.
Verein für Gefährdetenhilfe Bonn, Bonn, Germany.
Soc Sci Med. 2024 Feb;342:116561. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2024.116561. Epub 2024 Jan 9.
Access to safe and affordable drinking water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) for all is needed to safeguard human health, high on societal and political agendas. According to official estimates, populations in high-income countries (HICs) are well served. Vulnerable communities at the margins of rich societies, including people experiencing homelessness, however, are often underserved and overlooked. For them, safe WASH is often a dream rather than reality. To date, no study has been conducted in Germany - one of the countries most affected in Europe.
We chose a qualitative mixed-method approach to understand WASH (in)security challenges that people experiencing homelessness are facing. Data were collected in Bonn, Germany, from 25 people experiencing homelessness (in-depth interviews, arts-based workshops, group discussions), their service providers (social workers), and (un)available public infrastructure (inspections), in 2023. Data were analyzed following the dimensions of the Human Right to Water and Sanitation (HRTWS): availability; accessibility; affordability; acceptability; quality and safety.
People experiencing homelessness largely lack available, accessible, affordable, acceptable and safe WASH. Open urination and defecation are often the only alternative, resulting in substantial health risks and diseases. Women face particular challenges, especially while menstruating. Extreme weather events complicate existing WASH insecurity further, creating additional hardships for unhoused people and their service providers. The missed realization of the HRTWS has far-reaching consequences, making it harder to transition out of homelessness.
Much remains to be done to serve unhoused people in HICs better with WASH. Their experiences shed light on the underlying complexities, and the implications of different often interconnected challenges, including instability, mobility, preexisting diseases, mental health conditions and substance use disorder. Different insecurities exist among different sub-groups (e.g. women, people with limited mobility). They are valuable key informants for targeted health messaging and interventions.
为了保障人类健康,人人享有安全和负担得起的饮用水、环境卫生和个人卫生(WASH)服务已成为社会和政治议程上的当务之急。根据官方估计,高收入国家(HICs)的人口得到了很好的服务。然而,处于富裕社会边缘的弱势社区,包括无家可归者,往往服务不足且被忽视。对他们来说,安全的 WASH 往往是一种梦想,而不是现实。迄今为止,在德国——欧洲受影响最严重的国家之一——尚未开展过相关研究。
我们选择了定性混合方法来了解无家可归者面临的 WASH(不安全)挑战。2023 年,在德国波恩,我们从 25 名无家可归者(深入访谈、基于艺术的工作坊、小组讨论)、他们的服务提供者(社会工作者)以及(可用或不可用的)公共基础设施(检查)收集了数据。数据根据水和环境卫生人权(HRTWS)的维度进行分析:供应;可及性;负担能力;可接受性;质量和安全性。
无家可归者在很大程度上缺乏可用、可及、负担得起、可接受和安全的 WASH。经常只能选择露天大小便,这会导致严重的健康风险和疾病。女性尤其面临特殊挑战,尤其是在经期。极端天气事件进一步加剧了现有的 WASH 不安全状况,给无家可归者及其服务提供者带来了额外的困难。未能实现 HRTWS 会产生深远的影响,使他们更难摆脱无家可归的状态。
在高收入国家,还有很多工作要做,才能更好地为无家可归者提供 WASH 服务。他们的经历揭示了潜在的复杂性,以及不同相互关联的挑战的影响,包括不稳定、流动性、既有疾病、心理健康状况和药物使用障碍。不同的弱势群体(例如,女性、行动不便者)存在不同的不安全因素。他们是针对特定健康信息和干预措施的有价值的关键知情者。