Mushtaq Maryam, Mushtaq Yusuf, Khanna Aishwarya, Javed Ahmed
College of Medicine, Luton and Dunstable Hospital, Bedfordshire Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Luton, GBR.
Ophthalmology, Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust, Nottingham, GBR.
Cureus. 2024 Jan 31;16(1):e53288. doi: 10.7759/cureus.53288. eCollection 2024 Jan.
Clinical reasoning, specifically diagnostic decision-making, has been a subject of fragmented literature since the 1970s, marked by diverse theories and conflicting perspectives. This article reviews the latest evidence in medical education, drawing from scientific literature, to offer ophthalmologists insights into optimal strategies for personal learning and the education of others. It explores the historical development of clinical reasoning theories, emphasising the challenges in understanding how doctors formulate diagnoses. The importance of clinical reasoning is underscored by its role in making accurate diagnoses and preventing diagnostic errors. The article delves into the dual process theory, distinguishing between type 1 and type 2 thinking and their implications for clinical decision-making. Cognitive load theory is introduced as a crucial aspect, highlighting the limited capacity of working memory and its impact on the diagnostic process. The zone of proximal development (ZPD) is explored as a framework for optimal learning environments, emphasising the importance of scaffolding and deliberate practice in skill development. The article discusses semantic competence, mental representation, and the interplay of different memory stores-semantic, episodic, and procedural-in enhancing diagnostic proficiency. Self-regulated learning (SRL) is introduced as a student-centric approach, emphasising goal setting, metacognition, and continuous improvement. Practical advice is provided for minimising cognitive errors in clinical reasoning, applying dual process theory, and considering cognitive load theory in teaching. The relevance of deliberate practice in ophthalmology, especially in a rapidly evolving field, is emphasised for continuous learning and staying updated with advancements. The article concludes by highlighting the importance of clinical supervisors in recognising and supporting trainees' self-regulated learning and understanding the principles of various teaching and learning theories. Ultimately, a profound comprehension of the science behind clinical reasoning is deemed fundamental for ophthalmologists to deliver high-quality, evidence-based care and foster critical thinking skills in the dynamic landscape of ophthalmology.
自20世纪70年代以来,临床推理,特别是诊断决策,一直是文献分散的主题,其特点是理论多样且观点相互冲突。本文回顾医学教育的最新证据,借鉴科学文献,为眼科医生提供个人学习和他人教育的最佳策略见解。它探讨了临床推理理论的历史发展,强调了理解医生如何做出诊断所面临的挑战。临床推理在做出准确诊断和预防诊断错误方面的作用凸显了其重要性。本文深入探讨了双过程理论,区分了1型和2型思维及其对临床决策的影响。认知负荷理论作为一个关键方面被引入,强调了工作记忆的有限容量及其对诊断过程的影响。近发展区(ZPD)作为最佳学习环境的框架被探讨,强调了支架搭建和刻意练习在技能发展中的重要性。本文讨论了语义能力、心理表征以及不同记忆存储——语义、情景和程序记忆——在提高诊断能力方面的相互作用。自我调节学习(SRL)作为一种以学生为中心的方法被引入,强调目标设定、元认知和持续改进。提供了实用建议,以尽量减少临床推理中的认知错误,应用双过程理论,并在教学中考虑认知负荷理论。强调了刻意练习在眼科中的相关性,特别是在一个快速发展的领域,对于持续学习和跟上进展至关重要。文章最后强调了临床带教老师在识别和支持学员自我调节学习以及理解各种教学理论原则方面的重要性。最终,对临床推理背后科学的深刻理解被认为是眼科医生提供高质量循证医疗以及在动态的眼科领域培养批判性思维技能的基础。