Stiffness and pain secondary to end-stage dysfunctional osteoarthritis of the elbow can pose a therapeutic dilemma. Although total elbow arthroplasty is successful in older patients with low functional demand, alternatives to joint replacement must be found in the younger, more active individual. Interposition arthroplasty provides a salvage option for young, high-demand patients who hope to minimize functional restrictions of the affected extremity. The procedure traditionally involves release of both collateral ligaments and the joint capsule, resulting in a higher risk for postoperative instability and complications. The present unilateral technique demonstrates an approach maintaining the integrity of the medial or lateral collateral ligament while still allowing secure graft fixation. Stability can usually be preserved without ligament reconstruction or hinged external fixation if the elbow was stable before surgery.