Abdul Nishath Sayed, Alzahrani Jumana Abdullah, Alharbei Sarah Saad, Almutib Aldanah Tawfiq, Ibnjuma Reem Abdullah, Almutairi Zainab Hammad
Faculty of Oral Pathology, Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery & Diagnostic Sciences, College of Medicine and Dentistry, Riyadh Elm University, Riyadh, SAU.
General Dentistry, College of Medicine and Dentistry, Riyadh Elm University, Riyadh, SAU.
Cureus. 2024 Jan 15;16(1):e52333. doi: 10.7759/cureus.52333. eCollection 2024 Jan.
Background The establishment of human identity has always been a concern after mass disasters, and the role of odontology in forensics has greatly evolved. Nowadays, palatal rugoscopy is a widely used method in the recognition of human identity due to its uniqueness in the course, direction, length, form, position, and enduring nature against disintegration. Its easy applicability, cost-effectiveness, and prompt results can be applied to festering, scorched bodies and in the absence of missing upper limbs and fingers. This study was undertaken to evaluate palatal rugoscopy as a tool to recognize human identity and gender between two different ethnic populations. Methodology A cross-sectional comparative study was conducted in the Department of Oral Maxillofacial Surgery and Diagnostic Sciences, Riyadh Elm University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, to recognize ethnicity and gender among the Saudi and Kuwaiti populations. A total of 364 participants were selected from the outpatient department between September 2022 and December 2022. All 364 participants were distributed into two groups after the application of inclusion and exclusion criteria. After obtaining informed consent from all study participants, study models were prepared for final interpretation. The outlining of rugae was done with the help of a sharp graphite pencil, and the assessment of various parameters, including total number, length, direction, unification, and shape of rugae, was done. A comparison was made between the two populations. SPSS version 26.0 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA) was employed to assess variations in the mean values of both the total number and the distribution of rugae on the right and left sides across different ethnic groups and genders. Results In this study, a total of 364 participants were included. Of the total participants, 184 were Saudis and 180 were Kuwaitis, with 188 males and 176 females. A comparative evaluation of rugae among ethnic groups showed that Saudi participants had a mean number of 8.92 ± 0.660 palatal rugae, whereas in Kuwaiti participants it was 8.68 ± 0.649 (p = 0.001). When rugae length was assessed between genders among Saudi participants, it was found that the majority of participants had primary rugae with a length of more than 5 mm, and the difference was statistically significant (p = 0.002). The majority of Saudi males had forwardly positioned rugae, while the majority of Saudi females had more backwardly placed rugae. When rugae length was assessed in males and females among Kuwaiti participants, it was found that males had more primary rugae than females. This study found that the majority of Kuwaiti males had a wavy shape of rugae, while the majority of Kuwaiti females had more straight rugae. Conclusions This study concluded that among the two ethnic groups, the total number, length, direction, unification, and shape of rugae were different between genders, with significant differences in some parameters. Therefore, palatal rugoscopy might be useful as a tool to recognize gender and ethnicity and may provide better results when used as an additional tool along with other dependable forensic tools.
大规模灾难后,确定人类身份一直备受关注,牙科学在法医学中的作用也有了很大发展。如今,腭皱襞检查因其在形态、走向、长度、形状、位置以及抗分解的持久性方面的独特性,成为一种广泛用于人类身份识别的方法。其易于应用、成本效益高且结果迅速,可应用于腐烂、烧焦的尸体以及上肢和手指缺失的情况。本研究旨在评估腭皱襞检查作为识别两个不同种族人群身份和性别的工具。
在沙特阿拉伯利雅得伊玛目大学口腔颌面外科与诊断科学系进行了一项横断面比较研究,以识别沙特和科威特人群的种族和性别。2022年9月至2022年12月期间,从门诊部选取了364名参与者。在应用纳入和排除标准后,将所有364名参与者分为两组。在获得所有研究参与者的知情同意后,制备研究模型以供最终解读。用尖锐的石墨铅笔勾勒出皱襞轮廓,并对包括皱襞总数、长度、走向、连贯性和形状等各种参数进行评估。对两个人群进行了比较。使用SPSS版本26.0(美国纽约州阿蒙克市IBM公司)评估不同种族和性别之间右侧和左侧皱襞总数及分布均值的差异。
本研究共纳入364名参与者。在所有参与者中,184名是沙特人,180名是科威特人,其中男性188名,女性176名。不同种族间皱襞的比较评估显示,沙特参与者腭皱襞的平均数量为8.92±0.660条,而科威特参与者为8.68±0.649条(p = 0.001)。在沙特参与者中评估性别间的皱襞长度时,发现大多数参与者的主要皱襞长度超过5毫米,差异具有统计学意义(p = 0.002)。大多数沙特男性的皱襞位置靠前,而大多数沙特女性的皱襞位置更靠后。在科威特参与者中评估男性和女性的皱襞长度时,发现男性的主要皱襞比女性多。本研究发现,大多数科威特男性的皱襞呈波浪状,而大多数科威特女性的皱襞更直。
本研究得出结论,在这两个种族群体中,皱襞的总数、长度、走向、连贯性和形状在性别之间存在差异,某些参数存在显著差异。因此,腭皱襞检查可能作为识别性别和种族的工具有用,并且与其他可靠的法医工具一起用作附加工具时可能会提供更好的结果。