Shamla Fatima, Ali Tahoora, Chaudhari Bhushan, Chaudhury Suprakash, Saldanha Daniel
Department of Psychiatry, Dr. D. Y. Patil Medical College, Dr. D. Y. Patil Vidyapeeth, Pune, Maharashtra, India.
Ind Psychiatry J. 2023 Nov;32(Suppl 1):S100-S104. doi: 10.4103/ipj.ipj_227_23. Epub 2023 Nov 30.
News media reporting of suicide may influence the masses toward or against suicidal behavior. So, responsible reporting by news media is important to protect vulnerable people from the deleterious effects of media reporting. World Health Organization has issued guidelines for media reporting of suicide in this regard. We planned this research to evaluate the quality of online news media reports of suicide and attempted suicides in India.
We assessed a total of 210 news reports about suicide and attempted suicides (70 English, 70 Malayalam, and 70 Hindi) to evaluate the reporting of harmful and protective characteristics in news according to the World Health Organization guidelines for reporting suicide in media.
We found all three language media reported almost all potentially harmful characteristics with gender (100%), location/site of suicide in the headline (97.61%), precipitating life events (95.24%), mentioning term 'Suicide' in the headline (98.10%), monocausal explanation for suicidality (90.95%), suicide method in the headline (90.95%), an accompanying photo (92.38%), and suicide method (93.81%) being reported with highest frequency. Potentially protective characteristics were not included in most news reports with poor focus on awareness information. Vernacular language media were poor as compared to English news media about the quality of reporting suicide.
We found poor adherence to reporting guidelines by online news media for reporting of suicide with poor coverage of educative and awareness information for the general public. It underlines the need for improving awareness among media professionals about responsible reporting of suicide.
新闻媒体对自杀事件的报道可能会影响大众对自杀行为的态度,使其倾向或反对自杀行为。因此,新闻媒体进行负责任的报道对于保护弱势群体免受媒体报道的有害影响至关重要。世界卫生组织已就此发布了媒体自杀报道指南。我们开展这项研究旨在评估印度在线新闻媒体对自杀及自杀未遂事件报道的质量。
我们共评估了210篇关于自杀及自杀未遂的新闻报道(70篇英文、70篇马拉雅拉姆语和70篇印地语),以根据世界卫生组织媒体自杀报道指南评估新闻中有害和保护性特征的报道情况。
我们发现,所有三种语言的媒体几乎都报道了所有潜在的有害特征,其中报道频率最高的有性别(100%)、标题中自杀地点/场所(97.61%)、诱发生活事件(95.24%)、标题中提及“自杀”一词(98.10%)、对自杀原因的单因素解释(90.95%)、标题中自杀方式(90.95%)、配有照片(92.38%)以及自杀方式(93.81%)。大多数新闻报道未纳入潜在的保护性特征,且对意识信息关注不足。与英文新闻媒体相比,地方语言媒体在自杀报道质量方面较差。
我们发现在线新闻媒体在自杀报道方面对报道指南的遵循情况较差,对公众的教育和意识信息覆盖不足。这凸显了提高媒体专业人员对自杀负责任报道意识的必要性。