Department of Family Medicine, Aga Khan University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Blended & Digital Learning Network, Aga Khan University, Karachi, Pakistan.
BMC Med Educ. 2024 Mar 1;24(1):218. doi: 10.1186/s12909-024-05069-y.
To provide access to primary care and universal health coverage, Pakistan requires 60,000 trained family physicians by 2030. At present, most primary care is provided by general practitioners (GPs) who do not have any post-graduate training. Empowering GPs through competency-based programs, that strengthen their knowledge and skills, may be a cost-effective strategy for improving healthcare quality. We describe the development and evaluation of FamMed Essentials, a modular, blended-learning program to improve clinical knowledge and skills of GPs.
This is a mixed method study. We used the CIPP (content, input, process and product) framework for course development and evaluation. We describe the steps used in content development, strategies for teaching and assessments, and evaluation of strengths and weaknesses of the program. In depth focus group discussions were conducted to gather insight on participants' and faculty's perceptions regarding the program's effectiveness.
Of the 137 participants who have completed the program, 72% were women and 49% had been practicing for more than five years. We saw a significant improvement in knowledge across all modules (p = < 0.001) and perceived confidence in clinical skills (p = < 0.001). An objective assessment showed participants' competence in patient management. Participants reported a high level of satisfaction (4.4 ± 0.83 on a 5-point Likert Scale). Focus group discussions revealed a positive impact on clinical practice. Flexibility and use of different teaching and learning strategies were additional strengths. In addition, participants reported an interest in further training. Power outages were highlighted as a major challenge.
In resource-constrained health systems, a modular, blended-learning, competency-based program is helpful to upgrade GPs knowledge without impacting their busy schedules. Accreditation of such programs and provision of a career trajectory for the trained GPs are pivotal to expansion of such initiatives.
为了提供初级保健和全民健康覆盖,巴基斯坦需要到 2030 年培养 6 万名接受过培训的家庭医生。目前,大多数初级保健由没有任何研究生培训的全科医生提供。通过基于能力的项目增强全科医生的能力,强化他们的知识和技能,可能是提高医疗质量的一种具有成本效益的策略。我们介绍了 FamMed Essentials的开发和评估情况,这是一个模块化的混合学习项目,旨在提高全科医生的临床知识和技能。
这是一项混合方法研究。我们使用 CIPP(内容、投入、过程和产品)框架进行课程开发和评估。我们介绍了内容开发、教学和评估策略以及该计划的优缺点评估步骤。进行了深入的焦点小组讨论,以收集参与者和教师对该计划有效性的看法。
在完成该计划的 137 名参与者中,72%为女性,49%的参与者从业时间超过五年。我们看到所有模块的知识都有显著提高(p<0.001),对临床技能的信心也有所增强(p<0.001)。客观评估显示参与者在患者管理方面的能力。参与者报告满意度很高(5 分制,4.4±0.83)。焦点小组讨论显示对临床实践产生了积极影响。灵活性和使用不同的教学和学习策略是额外的优势。此外,参与者报告有兴趣进一步培训。停电是突出的主要挑战。
在资源有限的卫生系统中,模块化、混合学习、基于能力的项目有助于在不影响他们繁忙日程的情况下提升全科医生的知识。此类项目的认证和为接受培训的全科医生提供职业发展轨迹对于扩大此类举措至关重要。