Zukerman Naomi, Bottone Emily, Low Maya, Ogourtsova Tatiana
School of Physical and Occupational Therapy, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Front Rehabil Sci. 2024 Feb 27;5:1341740. doi: 10.3389/fresc.2024.1341740. eCollection 2024.
Children with neurodevelopmental disabilities (NDDs, e.g., cerebral palsy) and their caregivers face lifelong and impactful challenges, particularly during life-transition periods such as adolescence. One's resilience emerges as an essential ability to navigate this vulnerable phase. Resilience is a complex concept that embeds multiple factors on various levels. Little is known about what resilience factors are pivotal in youth with NDDs and their families as they transition into adolescence and how these are addressed as part of existing targeted interventions.
This review explored the concept of resilience in youth with NDDs and their families. Specific aims included describing salient resilience factors in adolescents with NDDs and their families and to describe how resilience is addressed as part of targeted interventions.
Using the Arskey and O'Malley framework, six steps were undertaken, including a comprehensive literature search ( = 5 databases), transparent study selection, detailed data extraction with a coding scheme ( = 46 factors), results' collating with numerical and inductive content analysis, and consultation with three key stakeholders.
The study screened 1,191 publications, selecting fifty-eight ( = 58; = 52 observational and = 6 intervention) studies. Findings revealed that resilience in this context is closely linked to more than forty factors across four levels (individual; family; school/peers; and community). Pivotal factors include social and emotional competence, optimism, and family/peer relationships. While existing interventions targeting resilience show promising results, few programs are available and generalizable to different NDDs. Stakeholders highlighted the importance of addressing resilience factors that are not targeted in existing interventions: caregivers' self-efficacy and self-esteem, as well as youth's and caregiver's confidence. Preferences for and advantages of online delivery for support programs and individual/group features also emerged.
The review emphasizes the need for a holistic approach to support youth with NDDs and their families during adolescence transition. To enhance their resilience, recognizing caregivers' roles, customizing interventions, and exploring new implementation formats are avenues that align with the current evidence and opportunities for practical development in this field.
患有神经发育障碍(如脑瘫)的儿童及其照顾者面临着终身且具有重大影响的挑战,尤其是在青春期等人生过渡阶段。复原力成为度过这一脆弱阶段的一项关键能力。复原力是一个复杂的概念,它在多个层面包含多种因素。对于患有神经发育障碍的青少年及其家庭在步入青春期时哪些复原力因素至关重要,以及这些因素如何作为现有针对性干预措施的一部分得到解决,我们知之甚少。
本综述探讨了患有神经发育障碍的青少年及其家庭的复原力概念。具体目标包括描述患有神经发育障碍的青少年及其家庭中显著的复原力因素,并描述复原力如何作为针对性干预措施的一部分得到解决。
采用阿斯基和奥马利框架,进行了六个步骤,包括全面的文献检索(=5个数据库)、透明的研究选择、使用编码方案进行详细的数据提取(=46个因素)、通过数值和归纳性内容分析对结果进行整理,以及与三个关键利益相关者进行磋商。
该研究筛选了1191篇出版物,选择了58项(=58;=52项观察性研究和=6项干预性研究)研究。研究结果表明,在这种情况下,复原力与四个层面(个体;家庭;学校/同龄人;以及社区)的四十多个因素密切相关。关键因素包括社交和情感能力、乐观主义以及家庭/同伴关系。虽然现有的针对复原力的干预措施显示出有希望的结果,但很少有项目可供使用且可推广到不同的神经发育障碍。利益相关者强调了应对现有干预措施未涉及的复原力因素的重要性:照顾者的自我效能感和自尊,以及青少年和照顾者的信心。还出现了对支持项目在线提供的偏好和优势以及个体/团体特征。
该综述强调了在青春期过渡期间需要采取整体方法来支持患有神经发育障碍的青少年及其家庭。为了增强他们的复原力,认识到照顾者的作用、定制干预措施以及探索新的实施形式是与当前证据以及该领域实际发展机会相一致的途径。