Seiler Annina, Milliken Aimee, Leiter Richard E, Blum David, Slavich George M
Department of Radiation Oncology and Competence Center for Palliative Care, University Hospital Zurich and University of Zurich, Switzerland.
Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, United States.
Compr Psychoneuroendocrinol. 2024 Feb 2;17:100226. doi: 10.1016/j.cpnec.2024.100226. eCollection 2024 Feb.
Healthcare is presently experiencing a global workforce crisis, marked by the inability of hospitals to retain qualified healthcare workers. Indeed, poor working conditions and staff shortages have contributed to structural collapse and placed a heavy toll on healthcare workers' (HCWs) well-being, with many suffering from stress, exhaustion, demoralization, and burnout. An additional factor driving qualified HCWs away is the repeated experience of moral distress, or the inability to act according to internally held moral values and perceived ethical obligations due to internal and external constraints. Despite general awareness of this crisis, we currently lack an organized understanding of how stress leads to poor health, wellbeing, and performance in healthcare workers. To address this critical issue, we first review the literature on moral distress, stress, and health in HCWs. Second, we summarize the biobehavioral pathways linking occupational and interpersonal stressors to health in this population, focusing on neuroendocrine, immune, genetic, and epigenetic processes. Third, we propose a novel Psychoneuroimmunological Model of Moral Distress and Health in HCWs based on this literature. Finally, we discuss evidence-based individual- and system-level interventions for preventing stress and promoting resilience at work. Throughout this review, we underscore that stress levels in HCWs are a major public health concern, and that a combination of system-level and individual-level interventions are necessary to address preventable health care harm and foster resilience in this population, including new health policies, mental health initiatives, and additional translational research.
医疗保健行业目前正面临全球劳动力危机,其标志是医院无法留住合格的医护人员。事实上,恶劣的工作条件和人员短缺导致了结构崩溃,并给医护人员的福祉带来了沉重代价,许多人承受着压力、疲惫、士气低落和职业倦怠。另一个促使合格医护人员离职的因素是反复经历道德困扰,即由于内部和外部限制,无法按照内心持有的道德价值观和感知到的道德义务行事。尽管人们普遍意识到了这场危机,但目前我们对压力如何导致医护人员健康不佳、幸福感降低和工作表现下降缺乏系统的认识。为了解决这个关键问题,我们首先回顾了关于医护人员道德困扰、压力和健康的文献。其次,我们总结了将职业和人际压力源与该人群健康联系起来的生物行为途径,重点关注神经内分泌、免疫、遗传和表观遗传过程。第三,基于这些文献,我们提出了一种新颖的医护人员道德困扰与健康的心理神经免疫学模型。最后,我们讨论了基于证据的个人和系统层面的干预措施,以预防压力并促进工作中的恢复力。在整个综述过程中,我们强调医护人员的压力水平是一个主要的公共卫生问题,需要系统层面和个人层面的干预措施相结合,以解决可预防的医疗伤害问题,并增强该人群的恢复力,包括新的卫生政策、心理健康倡议和更多的转化研究。