Sartania Nana, Alldridge Louise, Ray Clare
University of Glasgow.
University of Plymouth.
MedEdPublish (2016). 2021 May 17;10:132. doi: 10.15694/mep.2021.000132.1. eCollection 2021.
This article was migrated. The article was marked as recommended. Much attention is being given to the implementation of fair selection criteria for access to Medical Schools in the UK, in order to address an imbalance in social class representation in the medical professions. Largely overlooked however, are the disadvantages faced by potential applicants both before and after selection by the Medical Schools. Here, we explore the nature of the barriers - both real and perceived - to accessing, transitioning and progressing in the medical education system as experienced by 125 current students at three UK Medical Schools. An online survey was conducted and responses to open and closed questions were categorised on the basis of the number of Widening Participation (WP) flags (e.g. index of multiple-deprivation, parental education and school Higher Education participation rate). The results show that differences in economic, social and cultural capital that students acquire through their background impact on their chances of admission to medical schools, highlighting issues such as access to finance and privileged knowledge, with school support and work experience opportunities being less available to WP students. Equally, these students found the transition to Medical School harder, and highlighted a lack of peers from similar backgrounds, a perception of being less well prepared academically and generally finding it difficult to fit in. Money worries and having to work for extra income, exacerbated the feeling of not fitting in, by losing out on key extracurricular activities. The data presented stress the importance of early support of (potential) WP students in secondary schools, and of a strong support network throughout their medical education.
本文已迁移。该文章被标记为推荐文章。英国正在高度重视实施公平的医学院入学选拔标准,以解决医学专业社会阶层代表性失衡的问题。然而,很大程度上被忽视的是医学院选拔前后潜在申请者所面临的不利因素。在此,我们探讨了英国三所医学院的125名在读学生在医学教育系统中入学、过渡和进步过程中所面临的真实和感知到的障碍的本质。我们开展了一项在线调查,并根据拓宽参与度(WP)标志(如多重贫困指数、父母教育程度和学校高等教育参与率)对开放式和封闭式问题的回答进行了分类。结果表明,学生通过其背景获得的经济、社会和文化资本差异会影响他们进入医学院的机会,凸显了诸如获得资金和特权知识等问题,而WP学生获得学校支持和工作经验机会的可能性较小。同样,这些学生发现向医学院过渡更加困难,并强调缺乏来自相似背景的同龄人、感觉学业准备不足以及总体上难以融入。经济担忧以及不得不为额外收入而工作,因错过关键的课外活动而加剧了这种难以融入的感觉。所呈现的数据强调了在中学阶段对(潜在的)WP学生进行早期支持以及在其整个医学教育过程中建立强大支持网络的重要性。