Department of Public Health, Policy and Systems, Institute of Population Health, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK.
University of Portsmouth Dental Academy, Portsmouth, UK.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2024 Aug;52(4):581-589. doi: 10.1111/cdoe.12957. Epub 2024 Mar 20.
To investigate the relationship between socioenvironmental sugar promotion and geographical inequalities in the prevalence of dental caries amongst 5-year-olds living across small areas within England.
Ecological data from the National Dental Epidemiology Programme (NDEP) 2018-2019, comprising information on the percentage of 5-year-olds with tooth decay (≥1 teeth that are decayed into dentine, missing due to decay, or filled), and untreated tooth decay (≥1 decayed but untreated teeth), in lower-tier local authorities (LAs) of England. These were analysed for association with a newly developed Index of Sugar-Promoting Environments Affecting Child Dental Health (ISPE-ACDH). The index quantifies sugar-promoting determinants within a child's environment and provides standardized scores for the index, and its component domains that is, neighbourhood-, school- and family-environment, with the highest scores representing the highest levels of sugar promotion in lower-tier LAs (N = 317) of England. Linear regressions, including unadjusted models separately using index and each domain, and models adjusted for domains were built for each dental outcome.
Participants lived across 272 of 317 lower-tier LAs measured within the index. The average percentage of children with tooth decay and untreated tooth decay was 22.5 (SD: 8.5) and 19.6 (SD: 8.3), respectively. The mean index score was (0.1 [SD: 1.01]). Mean domain scores were: neighbourhood (0.02 [SD: 1.03]), school (0.1 [SD: 1.0]), and family (0.1 [SD: 0.9]). Unadjusted linear regressions indicated that the LA-level percentage of children with tooth decay increased by 5.04, 3.71, 4.78 and 5.24 with increased scores of the index, and neighbourhood, school and family domains, respectively. An additional model, adjusted for domains, showed that this increased percentage predicted by neighbourhood domain attenuated to 1.37, and by family domain it increased to 6.33. Furthermore, unadjusted models indicated that the LA-level percentage of children with untreated tooth decay increased by 4.72, 3.42, 4.45 and 4.97 with increased scores of the index, and neighbourhood, school, and family domains, respectively. The model, adjusted for domains, showed that this increased percentage predicted by neighbourhood domain attenuated to 1.24 and by family domain rose to 6.47. School-domain was not significantly associated with either outcome in adjusted models.
This study reveals that socioenvironmental sugar promotion, particularly within neighbourhood- and family-environments, may contribute to geographical inequalities in dental caries in children. Further research involving data on individual-level dental outcomes and confounders is required.
研究英格兰各地小范围内居住的 5 岁儿童的社会环境中糖促销与龋齿流行率的地理不平等之间的关系。
2018-2019 年国家牙科流行病学计划(NDEP)的生态数据,包括英格兰下一级地方当局(LA)中 5 岁儿童龋齿(≥1 颗牙因龋齿、缺失或填充而损坏到牙本质)和未经治疗的龋齿(≥1 颗未治疗的龋齿)的百分比信息。这些数据与新开发的影响儿童口腔健康的糖促进环境指数(ISPE-ACDH)进行了分析。该指数量化了儿童环境中糖促进的决定因素,并提供了指数及其组成领域(邻里环境、学校环境和家庭环境)的标准化分数,得分越高表示在英格兰的下一级 LA(N=317)中糖促销的水平越高。对于每个牙齿结果,建立了线性回归模型,包括分别使用指数和每个领域的未调整模型,以及调整领域的模型。
参与者居住在该指数所涵盖的 317 个下一级 LA 中的 272 个。患有龋齿和未经治疗的龋齿的儿童的平均百分比分别为 22.5(SD:8.5)和 19.6(SD:8.3)。平均指数得分为(0.1[SD:1.01])。平均领域得分分别为:邻里(0.02[SD:1.03])、学校(0.1[SD:1.0])和家庭(0.1[SD:0.9])。未调整的线性回归表明,儿童患龋齿的 LA 水平百分比随着指数得分的增加分别增加了 5.04、3.71、4.78 和 5.24,以及邻里、学校和家庭领域。一个额外的模型,调整了领域,表明邻里领域预测的这个增加的百分比衰减到 1.37,而家庭领域增加到 6.33。此外,未调整的模型表明,儿童未经治疗的龋齿的 LA 水平百分比随着指数得分的增加分别增加了 4.72、3.42、4.45 和 4.97,以及邻里、学校和家庭领域。调整后的模型显示,邻里领域预测的这个增加的百分比衰减到 1.24,而家庭领域上升到 6.47。学校领域在调整后的模型中与这两个结果均无显著相关性。
本研究表明,社会环境中的糖促销,特别是邻里和家庭环境中的糖促销,可能导致儿童龋齿的地理不平等。需要进一步研究涉及个人层面牙齿结果和混杂因素的数据。