Department of Political Science, University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden.
School of Public Administration, University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden.
Eur J Public Health. 2024 Oct 1;34(5):885-889. doi: 10.1093/eurpub/ckae067.
National action plans (NAPs) are key instruments for governing antimicrobial resistance (AMR). In Europe, we can now observe many countries updating their NAPs which raise two key research questions; what substantial modifications are states opting for, and how do they wish to address challenges related to AMR governance in a comparative perspective?
Building on a previous analytical classification, we address these two questions by examining data of updated versions of NAPs in 13 European Union member states covering seventeen elements related to AMR governance.
Our results substantiate the large variation with regard to both substantive issues and governance-related matters. Most tellingly, they highlight the growing importance of the One Health approach in updated versions of NAPs. Our analysis also shows that while substantive issues remain important, One Health and the coordination and collaboration issues it entails are becoming more salient in the second or third generation of NAPs.
Updated NAPs suggest that EU member states are becoming increasingly knowledgeable on the causes and consequences of AMR and how it needs to be addressed. The enhanced level of knowledge also leads these countries to address the next set of issues and challenges; to improve domestic and international coordination and collaboration. Thus, the revised NAPs present a noticeable development from substantive issues towards governance issues.
国家行动计划(NAPs)是治理抗菌药物耐药性(AMR)的关键手段。在欧洲,我们现在可以看到许多国家正在更新其 NAPs,这引发了两个关键的研究问题;各国正在选择哪些实质性的修改,以及它们希望如何从比较的角度解决与 AMR 治理相关的挑战?
我们在前一个分析分类的基础上,通过检查 13 个欧盟成员国中更新后的 NAP 版本的数据,来回答这两个问题,这些数据涵盖了与 AMR 治理相关的十七个要素。
我们的结果证实了在实质性问题和与治理相关的问题上都存在很大的差异。最明显的是,它们强调了在更新后的 NAPs 中,“同一健康”方法的重要性日益增加。我们的分析还表明,虽然实质性问题仍然很重要,但“同一健康”及其所涉及的协调和合作问题在第二代或第三代 NAPs 中变得更加突出。
更新后的 NAPs 表明,欧盟成员国对 AMR 的原因和后果以及如何应对 AMR 的认识不断提高。这种更高的知识水平也促使这些国家解决下一组问题和挑战;改善国内和国际的协调和合作。因此,修订后的 NAPs 呈现出从实质性问题向治理问题的显著发展。