DiRosa Elena, Van Deinse Tonya, Cuddeback Gary, Murray-Lichtman Andrea, Carda-Auten Jessica, Rosen David
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Virginia Commonwealth University.
Res Sq. 2024 Mar 28:rs.3.rs-4144413. doi: 10.21203/rs.3.rs-4144413/v1.
Individuals with mental illnesses are disproportionately incarcerated in jails, which have become mental health institutions across the US. Yet there is limited research describing mental healthcare practices from entry to release among multiple jails and states.
We conducted 34 semi-structured interviews with jail healthcare personnel across five Southeastern states.
We report results on challenges and practices related to mental health staffing, screening, additional evaluations and services, and discharge planning in jails. Initial mental health screenings were often restricted to the detection of suicidality and history of treatment and medications as opposed to current mental health symptoms. Use of validated mental health screening forms was uncommon. We found delays in care between the initial health screening and being evaluated by a mental health professional. Most jails reported primary responsibilities for mental health care as preventing suicides and managing psychiatric medications. Jails reported mental health care as challenging to manage, with high volumes of individuals with mental health needs, yet limited resources, especially regarding staffing. Discharge planning was limited despite reports of poor continuity of mental healthcare.
Jails have a constitutional duty and opportunity to provide adequate healthcare to individuals with mental illnesses, yet practices are insufficient and resources are limited across jails. Based on our findings, we recommend 1) greater adoption and revisions of jail health standards 2) system improvement that expands identification of mental illnesses and quicker, less variable follow-up mental health evaluations, 3) improved linkages and supports for community resources that prevent incarceration of this population.
患有精神疾病的人被不成比例地关押在监狱中,而监狱在美国已成为精神卫生机构。然而,关于多个监狱和州从入狱到释放期间的精神卫生保健实践的研究有限。
我们对美国东南部五个州的监狱医护人员进行了34次半结构化访谈。
我们报告了与监狱中的心理健康人员配备、筛查、额外评估和服务以及出院计划相关的挑战和实践情况。最初的心理健康筛查通常仅限于检测自杀倾向以及治疗和用药史,而非当前的心理健康症状。使用经过验证的心理健康筛查表格并不常见。我们发现从最初的健康筛查到由心理健康专业人员进行评估之间存在护理延迟。大多数监狱报告称,心理健康护理的主要职责是预防自杀和管理精神科药物。监狱报告称,心理健康护理管理具有挑战性,有大量有心理健康需求的人,但资源有限,尤其是在人员配备方面。尽管有报告称精神卫生保健的连续性较差,但出院计划仍然有限。
监狱有宪法规定的责任和机会为患有精神疾病的人提供充分的医疗保健,但各监狱的实践不足且资源有限。根据我们的研究结果,我们建议:1)更多地采用和修订监狱健康标准;2)改进系统,扩大对精神疾病的识别,并进行更快、更一致的后续心理健康评估;3)加强与社区资源的联系和支持,以防止这部分人群被监禁。