Graduate Program in Rehabilitation Sciences, Universidade Nove de Julho, São Paulo, Brazil.
Universidade Nove de Julho, São Paulo, Brazil.
Physiother Res Int. 2024 Apr;29(2):e2089. doi: 10.1002/pri.2089.
This study explores the linkage between the Measurement of Environmental Quality (MQE) and the International Classification of Functioning, Disability, and Health (ICF). Stemming from the Human Development Model-Disability Creation Process (HDM-DCP), MQE enhances understanding of how environmental quality impacts disability development across diverse socio-cultural contexts. Integrating MQE with ICF expands the perspective on disability formation beyond HDM-DCP, encompassing ICF's functioning approach.
To link the MQE with the concepts and categories of the ICF.
Two health professionals with adequate taxonomic knowledge of the ICF performed the initial linkage, which was based on updated standardized rules considering all hierarchical levels of the ICF. Linkage agreement between the first two assessors was measured using the Kappa (k) coefficient and respective 95% confidence intervals. In the absence of a consensus between the two assessors (k > 0.60), a third assessor was consulted to make the arbitrary decision of the final categories linked to the MQE.
Insufficient agreement between the two assessors was found for the linkage process (k = 0.52; p < 0.001), requiring the final decision from the third assessor. At the end of the process, 26 ICF categories were linked to the main concepts (MC) measured by the 26 items of the short version of the MQE. Ten ICF categories were linked to the additional concepts (AC) measured by the MQE. Moreover, the MQE addresses the five domains of the ICF component "environmental factors," with a predominance of the "services, systems and policies" domain (MC = 45.8% and AC = 40%).
The linkage of the concepts measured by the MQE to ICF categories enabled mapping the content of the MQE, identifying it as a promising tool for measuring environmental factors in accordance with ICF percepts.
本研究探讨了环境质量测量(MQE)与国际功能、残疾和健康分类(ICF)之间的联系。MQE 源自人类发展模型-残疾创造过程(HDM-DCP),增强了对不同社会文化背景下环境质量如何影响残疾发展的理解。将 MQE 与 ICF 相结合,扩展了残疾形成的视角,超越了 HDM-DCP,涵盖了 ICF 的功能方法。
将 MQE 与 ICF 的概念和类别联系起来。
两名具有 ICF 分类学知识的卫生专业人员进行了初步联系,该联系基于考虑 ICF 所有层次的最新标准化规则。使用 Kappa(k)系数及其相应的 95%置信区间测量了前两名评估员之间的联系协议。如果两名评估员之间没有达成共识(k>0.60),则咨询第三名评估员对与 MQE 相关的最终类别进行任意决策。
两名评估员在联系过程中发现一致性不足(k=0.52;p<0.001),需要第三名评估员做出最终决定。在该过程结束时,26 个 ICF 类别与 MQE 26 个短版本项目测量的主要概念(MC)联系起来。10 个 ICF 类别与 MQE 测量的附加概念(AC)联系起来。此外,MQE 涉及 ICF 组成部分“环境因素”的五个领域,其中“服务、系统和政策”领域占主导地位(MC=45.8%和 AC=40%)。
MQE 测量的概念与 ICF 类别的联系使 MQE 的内容得以映射,表明 MQE 是一种有前途的工具,可根据 ICF 观念衡量环境因素。