Banditsaowapak Patcharamas, Cheng Johnson Hsin-Chung, Chen Daniel De-Shing, Chou Michelle Yuching
School of Dentistry, College of Oral Medicine, Taipei Medical University, Taipei, Taiwan.
Orthodontic Division, Department of Dentistry, Taipei Medical University Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan.
J Dent Sci. 2024 Apr;19(2):773-786. doi: 10.1016/j.jds.2023.10.021. Epub 2023 Nov 30.
This scoping review investigated the evidence on the three-dimensional analysis of a posed smile in adults to discover any research gaps in this research area. Electronic searches of articles written in English were performed using the four databases of Embase, PubMed, Springer, and Web of Science with publications from 2010 to 2023. Reference lists were also manually searched to identify additional studies. The results showed that 13 cross-sectional descriptive studies from Asia, Europe, North and South America met our inclusion criteria. Studies mainly focused on linear and angle measurement for resting and smiling faces and landmark movement from resting to smiling. Most studies conducted analysis of smiles stratified by sex, ethnicity, smile type, dental occlusion, skeletal pattern, and age. Two studies compared smiling with the resting position and one study compared the attractive smiling group with the ordinary group. Our scoping review revealed the insufficiency of some measurement methods, such as those employing area, volume, and soft tissue thickness. Furthermore, few studies were conducted in Asian populations, and comparisons of various smile types, overjet types, horizontal skeletal patterns, and comparisons of smiles between people with untreated normal occlusion and those who had been orthodontically treated were lacking.
本综述性研究调查了关于成年人摆拍微笑三维分析的证据,以发现该研究领域的任何研究空白。使用Embase、PubMed、Springer和Web of Science这四个数据库对2010年至2023年发表的英文文章进行了电子检索。还手动检索了参考文献列表以识别其他研究。结果显示,来自亚洲、欧洲、南北美洲的13项横断面描述性研究符合我们的纳入标准。研究主要集中于静止和微笑面部的线性和角度测量以及从静止到微笑时标志点的移动。大多数研究按性别、种族、微笑类型、牙合、骨骼模式和年龄对微笑进行分层分析。两项研究将微笑与静止位置进行了比较,一项研究将有吸引力的微笑组与普通组进行了比较。我们的综述性研究揭示了一些测量方法的不足,例如那些采用面积、体积和软组织厚度的方法。此外,针对亚洲人群的研究较少,并且缺乏对各种微笑类型、覆盖类型、水平骨骼模式的比较,以及未经治疗的正常牙合人群与正畸治疗人群之间微笑的比较。