Berebichez-Fridman R, Berebichez-Fastlicht E
Departamento de Ortopedia y Traumatología, Centro Médico ABC. Ciudad de México. México.
Acta Ortop Mex. 2024 Jan-Feb;38(1):22-28.
Predatory journals are distinguished from legitimate journals by their lack of adequate reviews and editorial processes, compromising the quality of published content. These journals do not conduct peer reviews or detect plagiarism, and accept manuscripts without requiring substantial modifications. Their near 100% acceptance rate is driven by profit motives, regardless of the content they publish. While they boast a prestigious editorial board composed of renowned researchers, in most cases, it is a facade aimed at impressing and attracting investigators. Furthermore, these journals lack appropriate ethical practices and are non-transparent in their editorial processes. Predatory journals have impacted multiple disciplines, including Orthopedics and Traumatology, and their presence remains unknown to many researchers, making them unwitting victims. Their strategy involves soliciting articles via email from authors who have published in legitimate journals, promising quick, easy, and inexpensive publication. The implications and negative consequences of predatory journals on the scientific community and researchers are numerous. The purpose of this work is to provide general information about these journals, specifically in the field of Orthopedics and Traumatology, offering guidelines to identify and avoid them, so that authors can make informed decisions when publishing their manuscripts and avoid falling into the hands of predatory journals or publishers.
掠夺性期刊与正规期刊的区别在于缺乏充分的评审和编辑流程,这损害了发表内容的质量。这些期刊不进行同行评审,也不检测抄袭行为,接受稿件时不要求进行实质性修改。它们近乎100%的录用率是由盈利动机驱动的,而不顾所发表的内容。虽然它们吹嘘拥有由知名研究人员组成的享有声望的编辑委员会,但在大多数情况下,这只是一个旨在给研究人员留下深刻印象并吸引他们的幌子。此外,这些期刊缺乏适当的道德规范,其编辑流程也不透明。掠夺性期刊已经影响了多个学科,包括骨科和创伤学,许多研究人员对它们的存在并不知晓,使他们成为不知情的受害者。它们的策略包括通过电子邮件向在正规期刊上发表过文章的作者征稿,承诺快速、简便且廉价的发表。掠夺性期刊对科学界和研究人员的影响及负面后果众多。这项工作的目的是提供关于这些期刊的一般信息,特别是在骨科和创伤学领域,提供识别和避免它们的指南,以便作者在发表稿件时能够做出明智的决定,避免落入掠夺性期刊或出版商之手。