University of Cologne, Faculty of Medicine and University Hospital Cologne, Institute for Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, Kerpener Straße 62, 50937 Cologne, Germany.
University of Cologne, Faculty of Medicine and University Hospital Cologne, Institute for Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, Kerpener Straße 62, 50937 Cologne, Germany.
Eur J Radiol. 2024 Jun;175:111447. doi: 10.1016/j.ejrad.2024.111447. Epub 2024 Mar 26.
Robustness of radiomic features in physiological tissue is an important prerequisite for quantitative analysis of tumor biology and response assessment. In contrast to previous studies which focused on different tumors with mostly short scan-re-scan intervals, this study aimed to evaluate the robustness of radiomic features in cancer-free patients and over a clinically encountered inter-scan interval.
Patients without visible tumor burden who underwent at least two portal-venous phase dual energy CT examinations of the abdomen between May 2016 and January 2020 were included, while macroscopic tumor burden was excluded based upon follow-up imaging for all patients (≥3 months). Further, patients were excluded if no follow-up imaging was available, or if the CT protocol showed deviations between repeated examinations. Circular regions of interest were placed and proofread by two board-certified radiologists (4 years and 5 years experience) within the liver (segments 3 and 6), the psoas muscle (left and right), the pancreatic head, and the spleen to obtain radiomic features from normal-appearing organ parenchyma using PyRadiomics. Radiomic feature robustness was tested using the concordance correlation coefficient with a threshold of 0.75 considered indicative for deeming a feature robust.
In total, 160 patients with 480 repeated abdominal CT examinations (range: 2-4 per patient) were retrospectively included in this single-center, IRB-approved study. Considering all organs and feature categories, only 4.58 % (25/546) of all features were robust with the highest rate being found in the first order feature category (20.37 %, 22/108). Other feature categories (grey level co-occurrence matrix, grey level dependence matrix, grey level run length matrix, grey level size zone matrix, and neighborhood gray-tone difference matrix) yielded an overall low percentage of robust features (range: 0.00 %-1.19 %). A subgroup analysis revealed the reconstructed field of view and the X-ray tube current as determinants of feature robustness (significant differences in subgroups for all organs, p < 0.001) as well as the size of the region of interest (no significant difference for the pancreatic head with p = 0.135, significant difference with p < 0.001 for all other organs).
Radiomic feature robustness obtained from cancer-free subjects with repeated examinations using a consistent protocol and CT scanner was limited, with first order features yielding the highest proportion of robust features.
放射组学特征在生理组织中的稳健性是定量分析肿瘤生物学和反应评估的重要前提。与之前主要关注不同肿瘤且扫描-重扫时间间隔较短的研究不同,本研究旨在评估在无肿瘤负担的患者中以及在临床遇到的扫描间隔内放射组学特征的稳健性。
本研究纳入了 2016 年 5 月至 2020 年 1 月期间至少接受两次腹部门静脉双能 CT 检查且无明显肿瘤负担的患者,所有患者(随访时间≥3 个月)均根据随访影像学排除了宏观肿瘤负担。如果没有随访影像学或 CT 方案在重复检查中存在偏差,则排除患者。两名具有 4 年和 5 年经验的认证放射科医生在肝脏(3 段和 6 段)、腰大肌(左侧和右侧)、胰头和脾脏内放置并核对圆形感兴趣区,以使用 PyRadiomics 从外观正常的器官实质中获取放射组学特征。使用一致性相关系数测试放射组学特征的稳健性,将 0.75 作为稳健性的阈值。
在这项单中心、IRB 批准的研究中,共回顾性纳入了 160 例患者的 480 次腹部 CT 重复检查(每位患者 2-4 次)。考虑到所有器官和特征类别,只有 4.58%(25/546)的所有特征是稳健的,其中一阶特征类别(20.37%,22/108)的稳健特征比例最高。其他特征类别(灰度共生矩阵、灰度依赖矩阵、灰度游程长度矩阵、灰度大小区域矩阵和邻域灰度差矩阵)的稳健特征比例总体较低(范围:0.00%-1.19%)。亚组分析显示,重建视野和 X 射线管电流是特征稳健性的决定因素(所有器官的亚组之间存在显著差异,p<0.001),以及感兴趣区的大小(胰头无显著差异,p=0.135,所有其他器官有显著差异,p<0.001)。
使用一致的协议和 CT 扫描仪对重复检查的无肿瘤患者进行放射组学特征分析,其稳健性有限,其中一阶特征产生的稳健特征比例最高。