Konrad Karl L, Weissenfels Anja, Birkenmaier Christof, Baeyens Jean-Pierre, Kemmler Wolfgang, Wegener Bernd
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Ludwig Maximilian University (LMU), Munich, DEU.
Experimental Anatomy (EXAN) Research Group, Department of Physiotherapy, Human Physiology and Anatomy, Vrije Universiteit Brussel (VUB), Brussel, BEL.
Cureus. 2024 Apr 8;16(4):e57858. doi: 10.7759/cureus.57858. eCollection 2024 Apr.
Recent clinical studies confirmed that whole-body electromyostimulation (WB-EMS) training is a safe and time-efficient therapeutic method for patients with nonspecific chronic back pain (NSCBP). However, significant variations in initial pain intensity among subjects in these studies have been observed. This study aims to determine if patients with differing initial pain intensities experience varying degrees of benefit from WB-EMS and to assess the overall correlation between initial pain levels and pain reduction.
Pain intensity datasets from two studies were combined. The pooled data included 121 NSCBP patients (38 males and 83 females) with an average age of 55.1 years (±11.8 years). Data was categorized by baseline pain intensity on the numeric rating scale (NRS) into seven groups: 0 to 2, >2 to 3, >3 to 4, >4 to 5, >5 to 6, >6 to 7, and >7. Both absolute and relative changes were analyzed. Additionally, a Spearman rho correlation test was performed on the entire dataset to evaluate the relationship between initial pain level and pain reduction.
Significant improvements were noted across all NRS11 categories, with strong effect sizes (p) in all classes above 2, ranging from 0.56 to 0.90. The >7 category exhibited the highest rate of clinically significant changes (80%) and an average improvement of 3.72 points. The overall group from >1 to 10 showed an average improvement of 1.33 points, with 37% of the participants experiencing clinically significant improvements. The Spearman rho correlation test revealed a moderate positive relationship between initial pain level and pain reduction (r_s = 0.531, p < 0.001), indicating that, generally, higher initial pain levels are associated with greater pain reduction.
The findings support the hypothesis that NSCBP patients with higher baseline NRS values benefit more substantially from WB-EMS. Those with NRS values above 7 show the greatest improvement and highest rate of clinical significance. The overall positive correlation between initial pain intensity and pain reduction further underscores the efficacy of WB-EMS in managing NSCBP across different pain intensities.
近期临床研究证实,全身肌电刺激(WB - EMS)训练对于非特异性慢性背痛(NSCBP)患者而言是一种安全且高效的治疗方法。然而,在这些研究中,已观察到受试者的初始疼痛强度存在显著差异。本研究旨在确定初始疼痛强度不同的患者从WB - EMS中获得的益处程度是否不同,并评估初始疼痛水平与疼痛减轻之间的总体相关性。
合并两项研究的疼痛强度数据集。汇总数据包括121例NSCBP患者(38例男性和83例女性),平均年龄55.1岁(±11.8岁)。数据根据数字评分量表(NRS)上的基线疼痛强度分为七组:0至2、>2至3、>3至4、>4至5、>5至6、>6至7和>7。分析了绝对变化和相对变化。此外,对整个数据集进行Spearman秩相关检验,以评估初始疼痛水平与疼痛减轻之间的关系。
所有NRS类别均有显著改善,2以上所有类别均有较强的效应量(p),范围为0.56至0.90。>7类别表现出最高的临床显著变化率(80%),平均改善3.72分。>1至10的总体组平均改善1.33分,37%的参与者有临床显著改善。Spearman秩相关检验显示初始疼痛水平与疼痛减轻之间存在中度正相关(r_s = 0.531,p < 0.001),表明一般而言,初始疼痛水平越高,疼痛减轻程度越大。
研究结果支持以下假设,即基线NRS值较高 的NSCBP患者从WB - EMS中获益更大。NRS值高于7的患者改善最大,临床显著性率最高。初始疼痛强度与疼痛减轻之间的总体正相关进一步强调了WB - EMS在管理不同疼痛强度的NSCBP方面的疗效。