Collier M A, Brighton C T, Rendano V T, Schryver H F, Kallfelz F A
Am J Vet Res. 1985 Mar;46(3):600-9.
Electrically induced osteogenesis exhibits a dose response curve and can induce bone formation in the absence of trauma and in nonunions. Electrically induced osteogenesis, using direct electric current (DC) in a third metacarpal diaphyseal osteotomy model, in conjunction with internal fixation and postoperative loading, was investigated. Twelve young adult ponies of mixed sex were divided into 2 treatment groups (A and B) of 3 stimulated and 3 controls each and evaluated, using a specifically designed procedure. Stimulated ponies in both groups were given 20 microA of DC via an implanted bone growth stimulator (BGS); group A ponies were stimulated for 60 days and group B ponies for 120 days. Biocompatibility of the BGS was excellent in all ponies. Radiographically, there was more advanced healing with better vascular development in the ponies stimulated for 60 days compared with controls, but no discernible difference was seen at 120 days. Nuclear medical bone imaging revealed a peak uptake at 4 weeks in stimulated groups and the uptake decreased after 8 weeks. Radiopharmaceutical uptake in stimulated ponies was consistently below control uptake throughout the study. Mean specific gravity (SG) of specimens prepared for testing materials properties for group A and B controls were 2.044 +/- 0.119 and 1.939 +/- 0.065, respectively. The SG for group A and group B stimulated were 1.992 +/- 0.049 and 1.876 +/- 0.031, respectively. The SG of specimens obtained from metacarpi of age-matched control ponies was 2.194 +/- 0.166. The ultimate bending strengths and the flexural moduli of elasticity in 60-day control ponies and stimulated ponies were 57 +/- 8.4, 59 +/- 23.9 MN/m2 and 89 +/- 3.5, 106 +/- 6.5 MN/m2 and in 120-day control ponies and stimulated ponies were 13 +/- 1.0, 13 +/- 3.2 GN/m2 and 13 +/- 2.89, 15 +/- 0.577 GN/m2, respectively. Sixty-day samples and 120-day samples had pending strengths (SU) of 25% and 50% that of unfractured cortex, respectively. These findings indicate that 20 microA of DC stimulation on a diaphyseal osteotomy model may not stimulate sufficient bone production to affect the mechanical properties of the bone. Therefore, based on our research, clinical use of BGS in fresh fracture management cannot be recommended.
电诱导成骨呈现剂量反应曲线,且能在无创伤和骨不连的情况下诱导骨形成。本研究在第三掌骨干骺端截骨模型中,使用直流电(DC),结合内固定和术后负重,对电诱导成骨进行了研究。12匹不同性别的年轻成年小马被分为2个治疗组(A组和B组),每组3匹接受刺激,3匹作为对照,并采用专门设计的程序进行评估。两组接受刺激的小马均通过植入式骨生长刺激器(BGS)给予20微安的直流电;A组小马刺激60天,B组小马刺激120天。在所有小马中,BGS的生物相容性都非常好。影像学检查显示,与对照组相比,刺激60天的小马愈合更 advanced,血管发育更好,但在120天时未见明显差异。核医学骨显像显示,刺激组在4周时摄取达到峰值,8周后摄取下降。在整个研究过程中,刺激小马的放射性药物摄取始终低于对照摄取。为测试材料性能而制备的A组和B组对照样本的平均比重(SG)分别为2.044±0.119和1.939±0.065。A组和B组接受刺激样本的SG分别为1.992±0.049和1.876±0.031。从年龄匹配的对照小马掌骨获取的样本的SG为2.194±0.166。60天对照组和刺激组小马的极限抗弯强度和弯曲弹性模量分别为57±8.4、59±23.9 MN/m2和89±3.5、106±6.5 MN/m2,120天对照组和刺激组小马的分别为13±1.0、13±3.2 GN/m2和13±2.89、15±0.577 GN/m2。60天样本和120天样本的待定强度(SU)分别为未骨折皮质强度的25%和50%。这些发现表明,在骨干截骨模型上施加20微安的直流电刺激可能无法刺激产生足够的骨量以影响骨的力学性能。因此,基于我们的研究,不建议在新鲜骨折治疗中临床使用BGS。