Musa-Maliki Ayishetu U, Duma Sinegugu E
Department of Nursing Science, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria.
School of Nursing & Public Health, College of Health Sciences, University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban, South Africa.
Heliyon. 2024 May 3;10(9):e30504. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e30504. eCollection 2024 May 15.
The benefits of routine screening for intimate partner violence (IPV) among pregnant women include early identification, prompt management, referral of IPV victims, and creating awareness about IPV. Despite these benefits, the practice of routine screening of IPV remains limited in midwifery settings in low-income countries. The purpose of this study is to identify and describe midwives' perspectives of the barriers in conducting routine screening of IPV for pregnant women in northern Nigeria.
A case study qualitative descriptive design was used to collect data from ten midwives in the antenatal clinic of a tertiary hospital. Non-participant observation and individual face-to-face semi-structured interviews were used as data collection methods. Thematic data analysis was carried out using Yin's five stage analytical cycle.
Three themes, with related subthemes, emerged from the data: (i) The theme of "Internal" barriers to IPV screening has four subthemes; midwives' personal discomfort in asking IPV- related questions, perceived mistrust of midwives by pregnant women, midwives' own perceptions of IPV as a personal matter, and midwives' lack of skills to screen for IPV. (ii) "External" barriers to IPV screening subsumes three subthemes: antenatal card related barriers, workload related barriers, and protocol barriers. (iii) "Structural" barriers to IPV screening have two subthemes: lack of space for privacy and lack of resources for managing pregnant women who have experienced IPV.
Knowing the barriers to midwives' screening practices is important because it may help in the development of contextually relevant and acceptable screening guidelines for midwives in Nigeria. Education and training of midwives will eliminate the internal barriers while the external barriers will need the intervention of hospital authorities and government to eliminate their effects on screening.
对孕妇进行亲密伴侣暴力(IPV)常规筛查的益处包括早期识别、及时处理、为IPV受害者提供转诊服务以及提高对IPV的认识。尽管有这些益处,但在低收入国家的助产环境中,IPV常规筛查的做法仍然有限。本研究的目的是识别和描述尼日利亚北部助产士对为孕妇进行IPV常规筛查的障碍的看法。
采用案例研究定性描述设计,从一家三级医院产前诊所的十名助产士那里收集数据。非参与观察和个人面对面半结构化访谈被用作数据收集方法。使用尹的五个阶段分析循环进行主题数据分析。
数据中出现了三个主题及相关子主题:(i)IPV筛查的“内部”障碍主题有四个子主题;助产士在询问与IPV相关问题时个人感到不适、孕妇对助产士存在不信任感、助产士自身将IPV视为个人事务以及助产士缺乏筛查IPV的技能。(ii)IPV筛查的“外部”障碍包含三个子主题:产前卡片相关障碍、工作量相关障碍和规程障碍。(iii)IPV筛查的“结构”障碍有两个子主题:缺乏隐私空间以及缺乏管理遭受过IPV的孕妇的资源。
了解助产士筛查实践的障碍很重要,因为这可能有助于为尼日利亚的助产士制定符合实际情况且可接受的筛查指南。对助产士的教育和培训将消除内部障碍,而外部障碍则需要医院当局和政府的干预来消除其对筛查的影响。