Department of Psychology, College of Literature, Science and the Arts (LS&A), University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
Department of Periodontics and Oral Medicine, School of Dentistry in Ann Arbor, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2024 Apr;88 Suppl 1:713-726. doi: 10.1002/jdd.13554.
Dental residents experience high stress in their demanding programs and gender-based harassment/discrimination can contribute to their stress. The objectives were to compare stress, satisfaction, experienced sexual harassment and observed discrimination of women in dental graduate programs with high, medium, and low percentages of women and to explore relationships between these constructs of interest.
Note that, 112 pediatric dentistry (PD), 44 prosthodontics, and 56 oral and maxillofacial surgery (OMS) residents responded to a survey.
PD residents had the lowest personal life-related stress (4-point scale with 4 = very stressful: PD = 2.99/P = 3.67/OMS = 3.56; p < 0.001), faculty-related stress (2.68/3.66/3.03; p < 0.001), lack of confidence-related stress (2.79/3.31/2.96; p < 0.01) and academic stress (2.65/3.24/3.02; p < 0.001), while prosthodontics residents had the highest stress levels. The average frequency of experiencing sexual harassment was highest for OMS residents and lowest for PD residents (5-point scale with 1 = never: 1.15/2.62/2.74; p < 0.001). PD residents observed least and OMS residents most frequently that female residents were treated less positively by other residents because of their gender (1.59/2.57/3.00; p < 0.001). Prosthodontics residents had the lowest job satisfaction score (5-point scale with 1 = lowest satisfaction: 4.12/3.14/4.20; p < 0.001). The more frequently male and female residents experienced sexual harassment, the higher their personal life-related stress, faculty-related stress, lack of confidence-related stress, and academic stress, and the lower their career satisfaction, specialty content satisfaction, and stress-related satisfaction. Women's frequencies of observed gender-based discrimination were associated with higher stress and lower satisfaction, while men's frequencies of these observations were not associated with stress, but associated with increased satisfaction.
Dental residents' stress, career satisfaction, experienced sexual harassment, and observed discrimination of women residents differ depending on the dental specialty program. Both male and female residents report more stress and less satisfaction the more they experience sexual harassment. The more women observe discrimination of women, the more stressed and the less satisfied they are. For men, the frequencies of these observations are not associated with stress, but positively associated with increased satisfaction.
牙科住院医师在要求苛刻的课程中承受着巨大的压力,而基于性别的骚扰/歧视可能会增加他们的压力。本研究的目的是比较高、中、低女性比例的牙科研究生项目中女性的压力、满意度、经历的性骚扰和观察到的歧视,并探讨这些感兴趣的结构之间的关系。
请注意,有 112 名儿童牙科(PD)、44 名修复牙科和 56 名口腔颌面外科(OMS)住院医师对一项调查做出了回应。
PD 住院医师的个人生活相关压力最低(4 分制,4=压力非常大:PD=2.99/P=3.67/OMS=3.56;p<0.001)、与教员相关的压力(2.68/3.66/3.03;p<0.001)、缺乏信心相关的压力(2.79/3.31/2.96;p<0.01)和学术压力(2.65/3.24/3.02;p<0.001),而修复牙科住院医师的压力水平最高。OMS 住院医师经历性骚扰的平均频率最高,PD 住院医师经历性骚扰的平均频率最低(5 分制,1=从未:1.15/2.62/2.74;p<0.001)。PD 住院医师观察到的频率最低,而 OMS 住院医师观察到的频率最高,即女住院医师因为性别而受到其他住院医师的负面对待(1.59/2.57/3.00;p<0.001)。修复牙科住院医师的工作满意度评分最低(5 分制,1=最低满意度:4.12/3.14/4.20;p<0.001)。男性和女性住院医师经历性骚扰的频率越高,他们的个人生活相关压力、与教员相关的压力、缺乏信心相关的压力和学术压力就越高,而他们的职业满意度、专业内容满意度和与压力相关的满意度就越低。女性观察到的基于性别的歧视频率与更高的压力和更低的满意度相关,而男性观察到的这些频率与压力无关,但与满意度增加相关。
牙科住院医师的压力、职业满意度、经历的性骚扰和观察到的女住院医师的歧视因牙科专业项目而异。男性和女性住院医师经历性骚扰的次数越多,他们的压力就越大,满意度就越低。女性观察到的歧视女性的频率越高,她们的压力就越大,满意度就越低。对于男性来说,这些观察结果的频率与压力无关,但与满意度的增加呈正相关。