Mena Jorge, Fandiño-Losada Andrés, Gutiérrez María Isabel
CISALVA Institute, Universidad del Valle, Cali, Colombia
CISALVA Institute, Universidad del Valle, Cali, Colombia.
Inj Prev. 2025 May 20;31(3):191-197. doi: 10.1136/ip-2023-045068.
Restrictions of male passengers of motorcycles to prevent homicides is a long-standing policy in Cali, Colombia. For some periods of time, the policy was suspended and then put into action again. All these changes were never evaluated and there has been controversy due to the perception of citizens, specifically motorcycle users, that the law was properly implemented in some periods and poorly applied in others. Our aim was to examine the effect of the non-application of the motorcycle male passenger restriction policy on the risk of homicides in Cali, Colombia.
Ecologic study conducted using an interrupted time series analysis. The main outcome was the aggregated daily counts of homicides. Secondary outcomes were the aggregated daily counts of homicides using a motorcycle and using motorcycle and firearm. Incidence rate ratios (IRR) were obtained by comparing periods of policy implementation with periods of lack of implementation in autoregressive negative binomial regression models.
There was an increased risk of homicides when the policy was not implemented (IRR=1.12; 1.05-1.19). There was no effect on the risk of homicides committed in motorcycles (IRR=0.98; 0.88-1.10) and when a motorcycle and firearm were used (IRR=0.99; 0.89-1.10).
The lack of implementation of the ban of motorcycle male passengers was associated with an increased risk of homicides. Our findings support the importance of this policy to prevent homicides in Cali, Colombia. Future work should examine how this policy influences other policies related to prevent homicide and violent risk-related behaviour.
在哥伦比亚的卡利,限制摩托车男性乘客以预防杀人案是一项长期政策。在某些时间段,该政策被暂停,之后又重新实施。所有这些变化从未得到评估,并且由于公民,特别是摩托车使用者认为该法律在某些时期实施得当,而在其他时期实施不力,因此一直存在争议。我们的目的是研究在哥伦比亚卡利不实施摩托车男性乘客限制政策对杀人案风险的影响。
采用中断时间序列分析进行生态学研究。主要结局是杀人案的每日汇总计数。次要结局是使用摩托车杀人案以及使用摩托车和枪支杀人案的每日汇总计数。通过在自回归负二项回归模型中比较政策实施期和未实施期来获得发病率比(IRR)。
政策未实施时杀人案风险增加(IRR = 1.12;1.05 - 至1.19)。对使用摩托车杀人案风险(IRR = 0.98;0.88 - 1.10)以及使用摩托车和枪支杀人案风险(IRR = 0.99;0.89 - 1.10)没有影响。
不实施禁止摩托车男性乘客政策与杀人案风险增加相关。我们的研究结果支持了该政策对预防哥伦比亚卡利杀人案的重要性。未来的工作应研究该政策如何影响与预防杀人案及暴力风险相关行为的其他政策。