Qi Ying, Zhao Pengfei, Bai Ruobing, Shao Yun, Pan Shinong, Hou Yang
Department of Radiology, Shengjing Hospital of China Medical University, Shenyang, Liaoning, China.
Department of Pharmacology, School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, China Medical University, Shenyang, Liaoning, China.
Med Teach. 2025 Mar;47(3):521-533. doi: 10.1080/0142159X.2024.2351138. Epub 2024 May 26.
Radiology instruction focuses on cultivating medical students' diagnostic thinking skills and practical competence, and lecture-based learning (LBL) is the most commonly used teaching approach. While fact-based, this type of traditional instruction is often non-engaging, leading to a shift toward student-centered models, one of which is the flipped classroom (FC). However, studies involving a comprehensive evaluation of students' experiences using the FC approach and its effects on their learning are lacking. Therefore, this study analyzed the teaching efficacy of the FC approach based on data of large groups of radiology students, accumulated over time.
Data from 636 medical radiology students taught using the FC and LBL models from 2012 to 2021 were retrospectively collected and analyzed.
The test scores of the FC group were significantly higher than those of the LBL group, and improvements in learning initiative and learning ability were notably higher in the FC than in the LBL group. The two groups showed no significant difference in the critical thinking disposition indicator, and the proportion of students with positive critical thinking tendencies was higher in the FC than in the LBL group. The academic and social self-perception scores of the FC group were significantly higher than those of the LBL group, and there was a significant difference in Kolb's learning style.
Based on evidence of completing pre-, in-, and after-class work, the FC approach improved students' academic performance, learning initiative, diagnostic ability, and satisfaction with learning and the teaching institution. Our findings suggest that FC instruction promotes students' assimilation and convergence of learning styles, and cultivates positive critical thinking.
放射学教学侧重于培养医学生的诊断思维能力和实践能力,基于讲座的学习(LBL)是最常用的教学方法。虽然这种传统教学基于事实,但往往缺乏吸引力,导致教学模式向以学生为中心转变,其中之一就是翻转课堂(FC)。然而,缺乏对学生使用翻转课堂方法的体验及其对学习效果的全面评估研究。因此,本研究基于长期积累的大量放射学学生数据,分析了翻转课堂方法的教学效果。
回顾性收集并分析了2012年至2021年期间使用翻转课堂和基于讲座学习模式授课的636名医科放射学学生的数据。
翻转课堂组的考试成绩显著高于基于讲座学习组,翻转课堂组在学习主动性和学习能力方面的提升明显高于基于讲座学习组。两组在批判性思维倾向指标上无显著差异,翻转课堂组中具有积极批判性思维倾向的学生比例高于基于讲座学习组。翻转课堂组的学业和社会自我认知得分显著高于基于讲座学习组,在科尔布学习风格上存在显著差异。
基于完成课前、课中及课后作业的证据,翻转课堂方法提高了学生的学业成绩、学习主动性、诊断能力以及对学习和教学机构的满意度。我们的研究结果表明,翻转课堂教学促进了学生学习风格的同化和融合,并培养了积极的批判性思维。