Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Warren Alpert Medical School of Brown University; Center for Digital Health, Brown School of Public Health, Providence, Rhode Island.
Hassenfeld Child Health Innovation Institute, Brown School of Public Health, Providence, Rhode Island.
R I Med J (2013). 2024 Jun 3;107(6):17-18.
Remote self-measured blood pressure (SMBP) programs improve racial health equity among postpartum people with hypertensive disorders of pregnancy (HDP) who receive recommended blood pressure ascertainment after hospital discharge.1-3 However, as prior studies have been conducted within racially diverse but ethnically homogeneous populations,1-3 the effect of SMBP programs on ethnicity-based inequities is less understood.4 We examined whether SMBP rates differed among Hispanic versus non-Hispanic participants in remote SMBP programs.
This is a planned secondary analysis of a RCT conducted among postpartum patients with HDP who were enrolled into our remote SMBP program, in which they obtain SMBP and then manually enter the SMBP value into a patient portal for individual provider response. In the parent trial, consenting patients were randomized to continued manual blood pressure entry of SMBP or use of a Bluetooth-enabled blood pressure cuff synched to a smartphone application utilizing artificial intelligence to respond to each obtained blood pressure or symptom for six weeks and to flag abnormalities for providers. Both SMBP programs were available in Spanish and English. For this study, women who self-reported their ethnicity were stratified into two ethnic groups - Hispanic and non-Hispanic - regardless of randomization group. Those who did not self-report ethnicity but completed all study procedures in Spanish were also categorized as Hispanic. Outcomes were the same in the parent study and this secondary analysis. The primary outcome was ≥1 SMBP assessment within 10 days postpartum. Secondary outcomes included number of blood pressure assessments and healthcare utilization outcomes (remote antihypertensive medication initiation or dose-increase and presentation to the Emergency Department or readmission for hypertension within 30 days of discharge). Participants rated their experience with SMBP via a scale from 0 (worst possible) to 10 (best possible) and the Decision Regret Scale, which assessed their regret in SMBP program participation (0=no regret; 100=high regret)).5 Outcomes were compared between groups. Risk differences (RD) were calculated for categorical and regression coefficients for continuous outcomes. The parent RCT was IRB-approved and published on clinicaltrials.gov (NCT05595629) before enrollment.
Among 119 women in the parent study, 83 (70%) self-reported ethnicity and the proportion of Hispanic people was similar in both treatment groups. This study compared 23 Hispanic (19% monolingual in Spanish) to 62 non-Hispanic women. Rates of SMBP assessment within 10 days postpartum was similar (Hispanic 64% vs non-Hispanic 79%; RD -0.1 (95% Confidence Interval (CI) -0.4, 0.1). There were no differences in mean number of remote SMBP assessments or rates of remote antihypertensive medication initiation or dose titration. The rates of hypertension-related presentations to the Emergency Department or hospital readmission were also similar between groups. Lastly, regardless of ethnicity, participants had low scores on the Decision Regret Scale and rated their experience with their remote SMBP program highly favorably. (See Table 1.) Conclusion: Hispanic and non-Hispanic postpartum patients with HDP had similar outcomes and favorable patient perceptions. The small sample size in this study may have produced inadequate power to detect a difference between study groups, thereby leading to Type II error. Thus, more research on Hispanic participants in remote SMBP programs is needed. However, the effect of remote SMBP programs on perinatal equity may not be limited to race-based disparities.
远程自我测量血压(SMBP)计划改善了患有妊娠高血压疾病(HDP)的产后人群的种族健康公平,这些人在出院后接受了推荐的血压评估。1-3 然而,由于之前的研究是在种族多样化但民族单一的人群中进行的,1-3 因此,SMBP 计划对基于族裔的不平等的影响了解较少。4 我们研究了在远程 SMBP 计划中,西班牙裔与非西班牙裔参与者的 SMBP 率是否存在差异。
这是一项针对患有 HDP 的产后患者进行的 RCT 的计划二次分析,这些患者被纳入我们的远程 SMBP 计划,他们在该计划中获得 SMBP,然后手动将 SMBP 值输入患者门户,以便个人提供者做出回应。在母试验中,同意的患者被随机分配到继续手动输入 SMBP 或使用与智能手机应用程序同步的蓝牙血压袖带,该应用程序利用人工智能来响应每一次获得的血压或症状,为期六周,并为提供者标记异常。两种 SMBP 方案均提供西班牙语和英语两种语言。在这项研究中,自我报告族裔的女性被分为两个族裔群体 - 西班牙裔和非西班牙裔 - 无论随机分组如何。那些没有自我报告族裔但用西班牙语完成所有研究程序的人也被归类为西班牙裔。该研究的结果与母试验相同。主要结果是产后 10 天内进行≥1 次 SMBP 评估。次要结果包括血压评估次数和医疗保健利用结果(远程开始使用抗高血压药物或增加剂量以及在出院后 30 天内因高血压就诊于急诊室或再次入院)。参与者通过 0(最差)到 10(最好)的评分以及决策后悔量表来评估他们对 SMBP 的体验,该量表评估了他们对 SMBP 计划参与的后悔程度(0=不后悔;100=高度后悔)。5 比较了两组之间的结果。对于分类结果,计算了风险差异(RD),对于连续结果,计算了回归系数。该母 RCT 在招募前已获得 IRB 批准并在 clinicaltrials.gov 上公布(NCT05595629)。
在母研究的 119 名女性中,83 名(70%)自我报告了族裔,两组中西班牙裔的比例相似。本研究比较了 23 名西班牙裔(19%只会说西班牙语)和 62 名非西班牙裔女性。产后 10 天内进行 SMBP 评估的比例相似(西班牙裔 64%vs非西班牙裔 79%;RD-0.1(95%置信区间(CI)-0.4,0.1)。远程 SMBP 评估的平均次数或远程开始使用抗高血压药物或调整剂量的比例没有差异。两组因高血压就诊于急诊室或住院的比例也相似。最后,无论族裔如何,参与者在决策后悔量表上的得分都较低,对他们的远程 SMBP 计划体验评价很高。(见表 1)。结论:患有 HDP 的西班牙裔和非西班牙裔产后患者的结局相似,患者的看法也较好。本研究的样本量较小,可能没有足够的能力检测研究组之间的差异,从而导致二类错误。因此,需要对远程 SMBP 计划中的西班牙裔参与者进行更多的研究。然而,远程 SMBP 计划对围产期公平的影响可能不仅限于基于种族的差异。