Biology Department, Evolution and Optics of Nanostructures Group, Ghent University, Ghent 9000, Belgium.
Museum of Comparative Zoology, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2024 Jun 11;121(24):e2318189121. doi: 10.1073/pnas.2318189121. Epub 2024 May 30.
Fluorescence, the optical phenomenon whereby short-wavelength light is absorbed and emitted at longer wavelengths, has been widely described in aquatic habitats, in both invertebrates and fish. Recent years have seen a stream of articles reporting fluorescence, ranging from frogs, platypus, to even fully terrestrial organisms such as flying squirrels, often explicitly or implicitly linking the presence of fluorescence with sexual selection and communication. However, many of these studies fail to consider the physiological requirements of evolutionary stable signaling systems, the environmental dependence of perception, or the possible adaptive role of fluorescent coloration in a noncommunicative context. More importantly, the idea that fluorescence may simply constitute an indirect by-product of selection on other traits is often not explored. This is especially true for terrestrial systems where environmental light conditions are often not amenable for fluorescent signaling in contrast to, for example, aquatic habitats in which spectral properties of water promote functional roles for fluorescence. Despite the appeal of previously unknown ways in which coloration may drive evolution, the investigation of a putative role of fluorescence in communication must be tempered by a realistic understanding of its limitations. Here, we not only highlight and discuss the key body of literature but also address the potential pitfalls when reporting fluorescence and how to solve them. In addition, we propose exciting different research avenues to advance the field of tetrapod fluorescence.
荧光,即短波长光被吸收并发射出长波长光的光学现象,在水生生物中,无论是无脊椎动物还是鱼类,都有广泛的描述。近年来,有大量的文章报道了荧光现象,从青蛙、鸭嘴兽,甚至是完全在陆地上生活的生物,如飞鼠,这些文章经常明确或含蓄地将荧光的存在与性选择和通讯联系起来。然而,许多这些研究都没有考虑到进化稳定信号系统的生理需求、感知的环境依赖性,或者在非通讯环境下荧光着色的可能适应性作用。更重要的是,荧光可能只是对其他特征选择的间接副产品的观点,往往没有被探索。对于陆地系统来说尤其如此,因为与环境光条件相比,荧光信号通常不适合在陆地系统中,而在水生栖息地中,水的光谱特性促进了荧光的功能作用。尽管色彩可能以以前未知的方式推动进化的观点很有吸引力,但在研究荧光在通讯中的可能作用时,必须对其局限性有一个现实的理解。在这里,我们不仅强调和讨论了关键的文献,但也解决了报告荧光时可能出现的潜在问题,以及如何解决这些问题。此外,我们还提出了一些令人兴奋的不同研究途径,以推进四足动物荧光领域的发展。