Department of Nutritional Sciences, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT.
University Writing Program, Women's Leadership Program, Women's, Gender, and Sexuality Studies Program and Department of Health Policy & Management, Global Women's Institute, Africana Studies, Jacobs Institute of Women's Health, Columbian College of Arts and Sciences and Milken Institute School of Public Health, George Washington University, Washington, DC.
Ethn Dis. 2024 Apr 24;33(4):170-179. doi: 10.18865/ed.33.4.170. eCollection 2023 Sep.
Black Feminism and Womanism offers an interdisciplinary lens and practice to center Black women's health, engage relevant health, and create Black women-informed solutions to address obesity. The purpose of this review article is to employ Black Feminism and Womanism to examine approaches and results of Black women-centered behavioral weight loss interventions.
A narrative review of Black women-centered behavioral weight loss interventions was conducted. To be included, articles met the following criteria: published between 2012 and 2022, standard behavioral treatment for weight loss, randomized design, weight loss outcomes stratified by race and gender, sample size of at least 75 individuals, adults at least 18 years of age, and at least 51% Black women in the sample.
Eight studies met the inclusion criteria for a Black women-centered behavioral weight loss intervention and were evaluated. Findings indicate that weight loss among Black women was mostly low, below the clinical target of 5 to 10% weight loss. Intervention designs ranged widely in their approach to respond to the context of Black women's lives, with little consistency between designs.
To make meaningful improvement in the effectiveness of behavioral weight loss interventions for Black women, new approaches are critical. Approaches grounded in Black Feminism and Womanism can provide the essential foundation to generate new knowledge, novel hypotheses, and intervention designs that fully attend to the lived context of Black women, including consideration of the potential health effects of gendered racism.
黑人女性主义和妇女主义提供了一个跨学科的视角和实践,以关注黑人女性的健康,参与相关的健康,并创造以黑人女性为中心的解决方案来解决肥胖问题。本文的目的是运用黑人女性主义和妇女主义来审视以黑人女性为中心的行为减肥干预措施的方法和结果。
对以黑人女性为中心的行为减肥干预措施进行了叙述性综述。符合以下标准的文章被纳入:发表于 2012 年至 2022 年期间、针对减肥的标准行为治疗、随机设计、按种族和性别分层的减肥结果、样本量至少为 75 人、成年人至少 18 岁、样本中至少有 51%的黑人女性。
有八项研究符合以黑人女性为中心的行为减肥干预措施的纳入标准,并进行了评估。研究结果表明,黑人女性的减肥效果大多较低,低于 5%至 10%的临床减肥目标。干预设计在回应黑人女性生活背景的方法上差异很大,设计之间几乎没有一致性。
要使行为减肥干预措施对黑人女性的有效性有意义地提高,就必须采用新的方法。以黑人女性主义和妇女主义为基础的方法可以为产生新的知识、新的假设和干预设计提供必要的基础,这些设计可以充分考虑到黑人女性的生活背景,包括考虑性别种族主义的潜在健康影响。