School of Health Sciences, University of Surrey, Guildford, Surrey, UK.
South East Coast Ambulance Service NHS Foundation Trust, Crawley, West Sussex, UK.
BMC Emerg Med. 2024 Jun 11;24(1):99. doi: 10.1186/s12873-024-01015-9.
Timely dispatch of appropriate emergency medical services (EMS) resources to the scene of medical incidents, and/or provision of treatment at the scene by bystanders and medical emergency lay callers (referred to as 'callers' in this review) can improve patient outcomes. Currently, in dispatch systems worldwide, prioritisation of dispatch relies mostly on verbal telephone information from callers, but advances in mobile phone technology provide means for sharing video footage. This scoping review aimed to map and identify current uses, opportunities, and challenges for using video livestreaming from callers' smartphones to emergency medical dispatch centres.
A scoping review of relevant published literature between 2007 and 2023 in the English language, searched within MEDLINE; CINAHL and PsycINFO, was descriptively synthesised, adhering to the PRISMA extension for scoping reviews.
Twenty-four articles remained from the initial search of 1,565 articles. Most studies were simulation-based and focused on emergency medical dispatchers' (referred to as 'dispatcher/s' in this review) assisted video cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), predominantly concerned with measuring how video impacts CPR performance. Nine studies were based on real-life practice. Few studies specifically explored experiences of dispatchers or callers. Only three articles explored the impact that using video had on the dispatch of resources. Opportunities offered by video livestreaming included it being: perceived to be useful; easy to use; reassuring for both dispatchers and callers; and informing dispatcher decision-making. Challenges included the potential emotional impact for dispatchers and callers. There were also concerns about potential misuse of video, although there was no evidence that this was occurring. Evidence suggests a need for appropriate training of dispatchers and video-specific dispatch protocols.
Research is sparse in the context of video livestreaming. Few studies have focussed on the use of video livestreaming outside CPR provision, such as for trauma incidents, which are by their nature time-critical where visual information may offer significant benefit. Further investigation into acceptability and experience of the use of video livestreaming is warranted, to understand the potential psychological impact on dispatchers and callers.
及时派遣适当的紧急医疗服务(EMS)资源到医疗事件现场,和/或由旁观者和医疗紧急呼叫者(在本综述中简称“呼叫者”)在现场提供治疗,可以改善患者的预后。目前,在全球的调度系统中,调度的优先级主要依赖于呼叫者的口头电话信息,但移动电话技术的进步为共享视频片段提供了手段。本次范围综述旨在绘制和确定当前使用、机会和挑战,即使用呼叫者的智能手机向紧急医疗调度中心进行视频直播。
对 2007 年至 2023 年间在英语环境下发表的相关文献进行了范围综述,在 MEDLINE;CINAHL 和 PsycINFO 中进行了搜索,按照扩展后的 PRISMA 进行了描述性综合分析。
最初搜索出 1565 篇文章,最终有 24 篇文章保留下来。大多数研究都是基于模拟的,主要关注于紧急医疗调度员(在本综述中简称“调度员”)辅助的视频心肺复苏术(CPR),主要关注视频对 CPR 表现的影响。有 9 项研究基于实际操作。很少有研究专门探讨调度员或呼叫者的体验。只有三篇文章探讨了使用视频对资源调度的影响。视频直播提供的机会包括:被认为有用;易于使用;对调度员和呼叫者都有安慰作用;并为调度员的决策提供信息。挑战包括对调度员和呼叫者可能产生的情绪影响。还有人担心视频可能被滥用,但没有证据表明这正在发生。有证据表明,需要对调度员进行适当的培训,并制定专门的视频调度协议。
在视频直播方面,研究还很匮乏。很少有研究将视频直播的使用重点放在除心肺复苏术以外的其他方面,例如创伤事件,这些事件从本质上讲时间紧迫,而视觉信息可能会带来显著的好处。有必要进一步调查视频直播的可接受性和使用体验,以了解对调度员和呼叫者的潜在心理影响。