Baran Leyla, Yeşil Yeşim
Faculty of Health Sciences, Mardin Artuklu University, 47100 Mardin, Turkey.
Department of Midwifery, Faculty of Health Sciences, Mardin Artuklu University, 47100 Mardin, Turkey.
Healthcare (Basel). 2024 Jun 14;12(12):1196. doi: 10.3390/healthcare12121196.
Developing a care plan for patients is not specific to nursing or midwifery; it is the case in every situation where patients seek help from care providers. Midwifery students draw upon NANDA-I diagnoses while developing care plans (CPs) in clinical practices, and plan and apply their care accordingly. This study aims to identify the views of midwifery students on the NANDA-I diagnoses and CPs that they use in clinical practice.
This descriptive and cross-sectional study was conducted with 222 students between September and December 2022. The research data were collected through face-to-face interviews using a questionnaire based on NANDA-I diagnoses and CPs. In line with the existing literature, the questionnaire was designed by two academicians who specialized in nursing fundamentals and midwifery. The questionnaire consisted of closed-ended (8 questions) and open-ended (7 questions) questions. Data analysis was performed with descriptive statistics and Pearson's chi-square test.
Of 222 students, 57.7% stated that they did not know the definition of a CP. It was found that 46.8% of the students felt inadequate at developing CPs. Furthermore, the students stated that they found the CP training provided during their undergraduate study partially sufficient, with a rate of 52.7%, and 16.7% of midwifery students offered suggestions about CP teaching. The number of midwifery-related diagnoses of which the students were aware was 19.
The study was beneficial in terms of identifying the deficiencies of the students related to NANDA-I diagnoses and developing CPs that might be overcome through education and observing the midwifery-related diagnoses that they used. It is of critical importance to educate midwifery students about midwifery-related NANDA-I diagnoses in order that they embrace midwifery diagnoses and CP learning.
为患者制定护理计划并非护理或助产专业所特有;在患者向护理人员寻求帮助的各种情况下都是如此。助产专业学生在临床实践中制定护理计划(CPs)时借鉴北美护理诊断协会(NANDA - I)的诊断方法,并据此规划和实施护理。本研究旨在确定助产专业学生对他们在临床实践中使用的NANDA - I诊断方法和护理计划的看法。
本描述性横断面研究于2022年9月至12月对222名学生进行。研究数据通过基于NANDA - I诊断方法和护理计划的问卷进行面对面访谈收集。根据现有文献,问卷由两位专门研究护理基础和助产的院士设计。问卷包括封闭式问题(8个)和开放式问题(7个)。数据分析采用描述性统计和Pearson卡方检验。
在222名学生中,57.7%表示他们不知道护理计划的定义。发现46.8%的学生在制定护理计划时感到能力不足。此外,学生们表示,他们认为本科学习期间提供的护理计划培训部分足够,比例为52.7%,16.7%的助产专业学生对护理计划教学提出了建议。学生们知晓的与助产相关的诊断数量为19个。
该研究有助于识别学生在NANDA - I诊断方法方面的不足以及制定可通过教育克服的护理计划,并观察他们所使用的与助产相关的诊断方法。对助产专业学生进行与助产相关的NANDA - I诊断方法教育,以使他们接受助产诊断和护理计划学习至关重要。