School of Nursing, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, United States.
College of Nursing, Suwon Women's University, Suwon, Republic of Korea.
J Med Internet Res. 2024 Jul 4;26:e56664. doi: 10.2196/56664.
Liver transplantation has become increasingly common as a last-resort treatment for end-stage liver diseases and liver cancer, with continually improving success rates and long-term survival rates. Nevertheless, liver transplant recipients face lifelong challenges in self-management, including immunosuppressant therapy, lifestyle adjustments, and navigating complex health care systems. eHealth technologies hold the potential to aid and optimize self-management outcomes, but their adoption has been slow in this population due to the complexity of post-liver transplant management.
This study aims to examine the use of eHealth technologies in supporting self-management for liver transplant recipients and identify their benefits and challenges to suggest areas for further research.
Following the Arksey and O'Malley methodology for scoping reviews, we conducted a systematic search of 5 electronic databases: PubMed, CINAHL, Embase, PsycINFO, and Web of Science. We included studies that (1) examined or implemented eHealth-based self-management, (2) included liver transplant recipients aged ≥18 years, and (3) were published in a peer-reviewed journal. We excluded studies that (1) were case reports, conference abstracts, editorials, or letters; (2) did not focus on the posttransplantation phase; (3) did not focus on self-management; and (4) did not incorporate the concept of eHealth or used technology solely for data collection. The quality of the selected eHealth interventions was evaluated using (1) the Template for Intervention Description and Replication guidelines and checklist and (2) the 5 core self-management skills identified by Lorig and Holman.
Of 1461 articles, 15 (1.03%) studies were included in the final analysis. Our findings indicate that eHealth-based self-management strategies for adult liver transplant recipients primarily address lifestyle management, medication adherence, and remote monitoring, highlighting a notable gap in alcohol relapse interventions. The studies used diverse technologies, including mobile apps, videoconferencing, and telehealth platforms, but showed limited integration of decision-making or resource use skills essential for comprehensive self-management. The reviewed studies highlighted the potential of eHealth in enhancing individualized health care, but only a few included collaborative features such as 2-way communication or tailored goal setting. While adherence and feasibility were generally high in many interventions, their effectiveness varied due to diverse methodologies and outcome measures.
This scoping review maps the current literature on eHealth-based self-management support for liver transplant recipients, assessing its potential and challenges. Future studies should focus on developing predictive models and personalized eHealth interventions rooted in patient-generated data, incorporating digital human-to-human interactions to effectively address the complex needs of liver transplant recipients. This review emphasizes the need for future eHealth self-management research to address the digital divide, especially with the aging liver transplant recipient population, and ensure more inclusive studies across diverse ethnicities and regions.
肝移植已成为治疗终末期肝病和肝癌的最后手段,其成功率和长期存活率不断提高。然而,肝移植受者在自我管理方面面临着终身挑战,包括免疫抑制剂治疗、生活方式调整以及应对复杂的医疗保健系统。电子健康技术有可能帮助和优化自我管理的结果,但由于肝移植后管理的复杂性,它们在这一人群中的采用速度一直很慢。
本研究旨在考察电子健康技术在支持肝移植受者自我管理方面的应用,并确定其益处和挑战,为进一步研究提供建议。
根据阿特塞和奥马利的范围综述方法,我们对 5 个电子数据库进行了系统检索:PubMed、CINAHL、Embase、PsycINFO 和 Web of Science。我们纳入了以下研究:(1)研究或实施基于电子健康的自我管理的研究,(2)包括年龄≥18 岁的肝移植受者,(3)发表在同行评议期刊上的研究。我们排除了以下研究:(1)病例报告、会议摘要、社论或信件;(2)不关注移植后阶段;(3)不关注自我管理;(4)不包含电子健康概念或仅使用技术进行数据收集的研究。使用(1)干预描述和复制指南和检查表以及(2)Lorig 和 Holman 确定的 5 项核心自我管理技能,对选定的电子健康干预措施的质量进行了评估。
在 1461 篇文章中,有 15 篇(1.03%)研究最终被纳入分析。我们的研究结果表明,针对成年肝移植受者的基于电子健康的自我管理策略主要针对生活方式管理、药物依从性和远程监测,突出了酒精复发干预方面的明显差距。这些研究使用了各种技术,包括移动应用程序、视频会议和远程医疗平台,但在综合自我管理所必需的决策或资源利用技能方面显示出有限的整合。所审查的研究强调了电子健康在增强个体化医疗保健方面的潜力,但只有少数研究包括双向通信或量身定制的目标设定等协作功能。虽然许多干预措施的依从性和可行性通常都很高,但由于不同的方法和结果测量,其效果有所不同。
本范围综述绘制了当前关于肝移植受者基于电子健康的自我管理支持的文献图谱,评估了其潜力和挑战。未来的研究应侧重于开发基于患者生成数据的预测模型和个性化电子健康干预措施,并纳入数字人际交互,以有效满足肝移植受者的复杂需求。本综述强调了未来电子健康自我管理研究需要解决数字鸿沟问题,特别是在老龄化的肝移植受者群体中,并确保在不同种族和地区开展更具包容性的研究。