社会处方链接工作者体验形成因素的元民族志研究。

A meta-ethnography of the factors that shape link workers' experiences of social prescribing.

机构信息

Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.

Oxford Internet Institute, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.

出版信息

BMC Med. 2024 Jul 4;22(1):280. doi: 10.1186/s12916-024-03478-w.

Abstract

BACKGROUND

Social prescribing is gaining traction internationally. It is an approach which seeks to address non-medical and health-related social needs through taking a holistic person-centred and community-based approach. This involves connecting people with and supporting them to access groups and organisations within their local communities. It is hoped that social prescribing might improve health inequities and reduce reliance on healthcare services. In the UK, social prescribing link workers have become core parts of primary care teams. Despite growing literature on the implementation of social prescribing, to date there has been no synthesis that develops a theoretical understanding of the factors that shape link workers' experiences of their role.

METHODS

We undertook a meta-ethnographic evidence synthesis of qualitative literature to develop a novel conceptual framework that explains how link workers experience their roles. We identified studies using a systematic search of key databases, Google alerts, and through scanning reference lists of included studies. We followed the eMERGe guidance when conducting and reporting this meta-ethnography.

RESULTS

Our synthesis included 21 studies and developed a "line of argument" or overarching conceptual framework which highlighted inherent and interacting tensions present at each of the levels that social prescribing operates. These tensions may arise from a mismatch between the policy logic of social prescribing and the material and structural reality, shaped by social, political, and economic forces, into which it is being implemented.

CONCLUSIONS

The tensions highlighted in our review shape link workers' experiences of their role. They may call into question the sustainability of social prescribing and the link worker role as currently implemented, as well as their ability to deliver desired outcomes such as reducing health inequities or healthcare service utilisation. Greater consideration should be given to how the link worker role is defined, deployed, and trained. Furthermore, thought should be given to ensuring that the infrastructure into which social prescribing is being implemented is sufficient to meet needs. Should social prescribing seek to improve outcomes for those experiencing social and economic disadvantage, it may be necessary for social prescribing models to allow for more intensive and longer-term modes of support.

摘要

背景

社会处方在国际上越来越受到关注。它是一种通过采取整体的以患者为中心和以社区为基础的方法来解决非医学和与健康相关的社会需求的方法。这涉及到将人们与他们联系起来,并支持他们获得当地社区内的团体和组织的资源。人们希望社会处方可以改善健康不平等现象,并减少对医疗保健服务的依赖。在英国,社会处方联系工作者已成为基层医疗团队的核心部分。尽管有关社会处方实施的文献越来越多,但迄今为止,尚无综合研究可以从理论上理解影响联系工作者对其角色的经验的因素。

方法

我们对定性文献进行了荟萃元分析,以开发一个新颖的概念框架,解释联系工作者如何体验其角色。我们使用系统搜索主要数据库、Google 警报以及通过扫描纳入研究的参考文献列表来确定研究。我们在进行和报告这项荟萃元分析时遵循了 eMERGe 指南。

结果

我们的综合研究包括 21 项研究,并提出了一个“论证线”或总体概念框架,该框架突出了社会处方运作的各个层面上存在的内在和相互作用的紧张关系。这些紧张关系可能源于社会处方的政策逻辑与实施它的物质和结构现实之间的不匹配,而这种现实是由社会、政治和经济力量塑造的。

结论

我们的综述中强调的紧张关系塑造了联系工作者对其角色的体验。它们可能会对社会处方和联系工作者角色的可持续性以及他们实现减少健康不平等或减少医疗保健服务利用等预期结果的能力提出质疑。应该更加重视如何定义、部署和培训联系工作者的角色。此外,应该考虑确保社会处方实施的基础设施足以满足需求。如果社会处方旨在改善那些经历社会和经济劣势的人的结果,那么社会处方模式可能需要允许更密集和更长期的支持模式。

https://cdn.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/blobs/8ed4/11225255/fb4d9c6e9df5/12916_2024_3478_Fig1_HTML.jpg

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索