Jeong Michelle, Weiger Caitlin, Uriarte Caitlin, Wackowski Olivia A, Delnevo Cristine D
Rutgers Institute for Nicotine & Tobacco Studies, 303 George Street Suite 500, New Brunswick, NJ, USA.
Department of Health Behavior, Society, and Policy, Rutgers School of Public Health, 683 Hoes Ln W, Piscataway, NJ, USA.
Prev Med Rep. 2024 Jun 13;44:102789. doi: 10.1016/j.pmedr.2024.102789. eCollection 2024 Aug.
E-cigarette marketing exposure may influence vaping-related outcomes among youth, but less is known on which specific advertising features impact youth attention, perceptions, and appeal. This study qualitatively examines responses to different e-cigarette advertising features among e-cigarette-naïve youth.
We conducted four online focus groups in 2021 with a national U.S. sample of 13-17 year olds (n = 25) who had never used e-cigarettes. Participants viewed and discussed their reactions to different e-cigarette advertisements varying in the inclusion of ad features, including color, models in imagery, text claims targeting smokers, and the nicotine warning label.
Participants were attracted to ads with bright colors, particularly when contrasted against a dark background. Ads featuring models attracted attention and reduced perceptions that the product is harmful. Comments indicated mixed reactions to smoker-targeted text claims. On one hand, participants perceived ads with text that specified "for smokers" as targeting older adults. On the other hand, text referring to "switching" from cigarettes to e-cigarettes led to some perceptions that the product is healthy, and certain text that implicitly referred to smoking (e.g., "no odor") had the potential to appeal to youth who wanted to use e-cigarettes discreetly. The level of attention paid to warnings depended on warning size and the color contrast between the warning and the rest of the ad.
Findings suggest specific e-cigarette ad features play an important role in attracting youth attention and influencing perceptions. More research is needed on the potential public health benefits versus unintended consequences of smoker-targeted text claims.
接触电子烟营销可能会影响青少年与吸电子烟相关的行为结果,但对于哪些特定广告特征会影响青少年的注意力、认知和吸引力,我们了解得较少。本研究定性地考察了从未吸过电子烟的青少年对不同电子烟广告特征的反应。
2021年,我们在美国全国范围内对13至17岁、从未使用过电子烟的青少年(n = 25)进行了四个在线焦点小组访谈。参与者观看并讨论了他们对不同电子烟广告的反应,这些广告在广告特征的包含上有所不同,包括颜色、图片中的模特、针对吸烟者的文字声明以及尼古丁警告标签。
参与者被颜色鲜艳的广告所吸引,尤其是当与深色背景形成对比时。有模特的广告吸引了注意力,并降低了对该产品有害的认知。评论表明,参与者对针对吸烟者的文字声明反应不一。一方面,参与者认为带有“针对吸烟者”字样的广告是针对成年人的。另一方面,提到从香烟“转换”到电子烟的文字让一些人认为该产品是健康的,而某些隐含提及吸烟的文字(如“无异味”)有可能吸引那些想 discreetly 使用电子烟的青少年。对警告的关注程度取决于警告的大小以及警告与广告其他部分之间的颜色对比。
研究结果表明,特定的电子烟广告特征在吸引青少年注意力和影响认知方面起着重要作用。对于针对吸烟者的文字声明的潜在公共卫生益处与意外后果,还需要更多的研究。