Yale University, School of Nursing, 400 West Campus Drive, USA.
St. Martins de Porres Hospital, Eikwe, Ghana.
Soc Sci Med. 2024 Sep;356:117153. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2024.117153. Epub 2024 Jul 19.
The purpose of this systematic review was to synthesize the components of interventions that are aimed at reducing stigma among adults living with chronic non-communicable diseases (NCDs). A secondary objective was to assess the effectiveness of interventions in reducing health-related stigma.
A search was conducted on OVID MEDLINE, OVID APA PsycINFO, EBSCO CINAHL Complete, Web of Science, and Cochrane Central in July 2023 for articles that report the development and/or testing of health-related stigma-reduction interventions among adults with NCDs. The quality of included studies was assessed using the Joanna Briggs Institute critical appraisal checklists. Intervention components were narratively synthesized. The DerSimonian-Laird random effect model was used to pool standardized mean differences across studies.
Nineteen articles were included in the review. Interventions addressed individual level (intrapersonal and interpersonal) and structural level stigmas. Components of intrapersonal interventions included cognitive exercises, stress reduction, promoting self-efficacy, developing communication skills, and listening to other patients' stories. Contact-based interventions were used in many interpersonal interventions. Structural interventions included mass media campaigns and training for healthcare professionals. Pooled intervention effects indicated a significant reduction in stigma levels post-intervention for both persons with NCD (Hedge's g = -1.13; 95% CI: 1.66, -0.60, I = 85%, N = 6 studies) and those without (Hedge's g = -2.45, 95% -4.84, -0.06; I = 97%, N = 2 studies).
Interventions to address NCD stigma, although multifaceted, are often not multilevel. Future studies are needed to design and test multilevel NCD stigma-reduction interventions.
本系统评价的目的是综合旨在减少慢性非传染性疾病(NCD)患者中耻辱感的干预措施的组成部分。次要目的是评估干预措施减少与健康相关耻辱感的有效性。
2023 年 7 月,在 OVID MEDLINE、OVID APA PsycINFO、EBSCO CINAHL Complete、Web of Science 和 Cochrane Central 上进行了搜索,以查找报告针对 NCD 成人开发和/或测试与健康相关耻辱感减少干预措施的文章。使用 Joanna Briggs 研究所批判性评估清单评估纳入研究的质量。通过叙述性综合方法综合干预措施的组成部分。使用 DerSimonian-Laird 随机效应模型汇总研究之间的标准化均数差异。
本综述共纳入 19 篇文章。干预措施针对个人层面(内在和人际)和结构层面的耻辱感。内在干预措施的组成部分包括认知练习、减轻压力、提高自我效能感、发展沟通技巧和倾听其他患者的故事。人际干预措施中经常使用基于接触的干预措施。结构干预措施包括大众媒体宣传和对医疗保健专业人员的培训。汇总的干预效果表明,干预后 NCD 患者(Hedge's g = -1.13;95%CI:1.66,-0.60,I = 85%,N = 6 项研究)和非 NCD 患者(Hedge's g = -2.45,95% -4.84,-0.06;I = 97%,N = 2 项研究)的耻辱感水平显著降低。
尽管针对 NCD 耻辱感的干预措施是多方面的,但往往不是多层次的。需要进一步研究来设计和测试针对 NCD 耻辱感的多层次干预措施。