Recombinant high-density lipoprotein (rHDL) as anti-atherosclerosis (AS) vehicle has unique advantages including multiple anti-atherogenic functions and homing features to plaques. However, rHDL may be converted into dysfunctional forms due to complex treatment during preparation. Herein, oxidation-induced dysfunction of non-split HDL and rHDL was initially investigated. It was found that although both non-split HDL and rHDL showed oxidative dysfunction behavior, non-split HDL demonstrated superior oxidation defense compared to rHDL due to its intact composition and avoidance of overprocessing such as split and recombination. Unfortunately, in vivo oxidative stress could compromise the functionality of HDL. Therefore, surface engineering of non-split HDL and rHDL with cascade antioxidant enzyme analogues Ebselen and mitochondrial-targeted TPGS-Tempo was conducted to construct a dual-line defense HDL nano system (i.e., T@E-HDLs/rHDL), aiming to restore plaque redox balance and preserving the physiological function of HDL. Results indicated that both T@E-HDLs and rHDLs performed without distinction and exhibited greater resistance to oxidative stress damage as well as better functions than unmodified HDLs in macrophage foam cells. Overall, the modification of dual antioxidants strategy bridges the gap between non-split HDL and rHDL, and provides a promising resolution for the dilemmas of oxidative stress in plaques and HDL self dysfunction.