Ruetters Maurice, Alexandrou Korallia, Ciardo Antonio, Awounvo Sinclair, Gehrig Holger, Kim Ti-Sun, Lux Christopher J, Sen Sinan
Department of Operative Dentistry, University Hospital Heidelberg, Im Neuenheimer Feld 400, 69120 Heidelberg, Germany.
Department of Orthodontics, University Hospital Heidelberg, Im Neuenheimer Feld 400, 69120 Heidelberg, Germany.
J Imaging. 2024 Jul 23;10(8):177. doi: 10.3390/jimaging10080177.
The aim of this study was to investigate the influence of examiner experience on measurements of bone-loss using high-dose (HD) and low-dose (LD) CBCT. Three diagnosticians with varying levels of CBCT interpretation experience measured bone-loss from CBCT scans of three cadaveric heads at 30 sites, conducting measurements twice. Between the first and second measurements, diagnostician 2 and diagnostician 3 received training in LD-CBCT diagnostics. The diagnosticians also classified the certainty of their measurements using a three-grade scale. The accuracy of bone-loss measurements was assessed using the absolute difference between observed and clinical measurements and compared among diagnosticians with different experience levels for both HD and LD-CBCT. At baseline, there was a significant difference in measurement accuracy between diagnostician 1 and diagnostician 2, and between diagnostician 1 and diagnostician 3, but not between diagnostician 2 and diagnostician 3. Training improved the accuracy of both HD-CBCT and LD-CBCT measurements in diagnostician 2, and of LD-CBCT measurements in diagnostician 3. Regarding measurement certainty, there was a significant difference among diagnosticians before training. Training enhanced the certainty for diagnosticians 2 and 3, with a significant improvement noted only for diagnostician 3. Examiner experience level significantly impacts the accuracy and certainty of bone-loss measurements using HD- and LD-CBCT.
本研究的目的是调查检查者经验对使用高剂量(HD)和低剂量(LD)锥形束计算机断层扫描(CBCT)测量骨丢失的影响。三名具有不同CBCT解读经验水平的诊断医生对三个尸体头部的CBCT扫描在30个部位测量骨丢失情况,进行了两次测量。在第一次和第二次测量之间,诊断医生2和诊断医生3接受了LD-CBCT诊断方面的培训。诊断医生还使用三级量表对其测量的确定性进行分类。使用观察到的测量值与临床测量值之间的绝对差值评估骨丢失测量的准确性,并在HD和LD-CBCT的不同经验水平诊断医生之间进行比较。在基线时,诊断医生1与诊断医生2之间以及诊断医生1与诊断医生3之间的测量准确性存在显著差异,但诊断医生2与诊断医生3之间没有差异。培训提高了诊断医生2的HD-CBCT和LD-CBCT测量的准确性,以及诊断医生3的LD-CBCT测量的准确性。关于测量确定性,培训前诊断医生之间存在显著差异。培训提高了诊断医生2和3的确定性,仅诊断医生3有显著改善。检查者经验水平对使用HD和LD-CBCT测量骨丢失的准确性和确定性有显著影响。