Kita Keiichiro, Watanabe Kazuhiro, Saito Mayuko, Kuroiwa Maiko
Department of General Medicine, Toyama University Hospital, Toyama City, Toyama, Japan.
PRiMER. 2024 Aug 14;8:45. doi: 10.22454/PRiMER.2024.576211. eCollection 2024.
Posterior canal-type benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV) is commonly treated using the Epley maneuver; however, the maneuver's use in primary care is limited by insufficient expertise. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate the efficacy of a three-dimensional (3D) semicircular canal model as a self-learning tool for primary care physicians to improve their Epley maneuver technique.
Thirty-one participants (18 family physicians, seven residents, and six medical students) performed the Dix-Hallpike maneuver on a nursing manikin, followed by the Epley maneuver on the covered 3D models before and after a 5-minute self-study period with the uncovered 3D model. We measured the number of moved beads from posterior canal into the utricle of the 3D model, time spent on the Epley maneuver, and head suspension angle of the Dix-Hallpike maneuver.
Preintervention performance was divided into a skilled group (n=7) that could move almost all the beads and an unskilled group (n=24) that could move a few beads. Postintervention, the unskilled group members significantly improved their skill: The average moved beads increased from 0.35 to 8.00, maneuver time from 26.1 to 35.8 seconds, and head suspension angle from 10.3° to 16.4°. Most participants recognized the importance of correct positioning and spent adequate time.
The 3D model was effective as a self-learning tool for improving Epley maneuver performance, particularly for less experienced practitioners. This approach could bridge the gap between evidence and practice in primary care for BPPV treatment, enhancing patient outcomes and reducing the need for specialist referrals.
后半规管型良性阵发性位置性眩晕(BPPV)通常采用Epley手法进行治疗;然而,由于专业知识不足,该手法在初级保健中的应用受到限制。因此,本研究旨在评估三维(3D)半规管模型作为初级保健医生自我学习工具以改进其Epley手法技术的效果。
31名参与者(18名家庭医生、7名住院医生和6名医学生)在护理人体模型上进行Dix-Hallpike手法,然后在使用未覆盖的3D模型进行5分钟自学前后,在覆盖的3D模型上进行Epley手法。我们测量了从后半规管移入3D模型椭圆囊的珠子数量、Epley手法所用时间以及Dix-Hallpike手法的头部悬吊角度。
干预前的表现分为能移动几乎所有珠子的熟练组(n = 7)和只能移动少数珠子的非熟练组(n = 24)。干预后,非熟练组成员的技能有显著提高:平均移动珠子数从0.35增加到8.00,手法时间从26.1秒增加到35.8秒,头部悬吊角度从10.3°增加到16.4°。大多数参与者认识到正确定位的重要性并花费了足够的时间。
3D模型作为一种自我学习工具,对于提高Epley手法的操作效果是有效的,尤其是对于经验较少的从业者。这种方法可以弥合初级保健中BPPV治疗的证据与实践之间的差距,改善患者预后并减少转诊至专科医生的需求。