ICAR-National Dairy Research Institute, Eastern Regional Station, Kalyani, West Bengal, 751235, India.
All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Bhubaneswar, Odissa, 751019, India.
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2024 Oct;31(47):57832-57855. doi: 10.1007/s11356-024-34956-6. Epub 2024 Sep 19.
This study investigated arsenic (As) concentrations in diverse environmental components and their potential impact on the health risks faced by residents of the arsenic (As)-contaminated Nadia district in West Bengal, India. A random selection of 182 cattle and 255 goats from 40 livestock farmers in the district revealed that both animals and humans were naturally exposed to elevated arsenic levels through contaminated drinking water, foods, grasses, concentrate feeds, various fodder tree leaves, and other food/feed resources. The mean As concentration in roughages (483.18 µg/kg DM) was significantly higher (p < 0.001) than in tree leaves (391.53 µg/kg DM), and concentrate feed/ingredients (186.66 µg/kg DM). Pond water exhibited higher arsenic levels (106.11 µg/L) compared to shallow tube well water (47.96 µg/L) and deep tube well water/tap water (10.64 µg/L and 10.04 µg/L, respectively). The mean arsenic concentration in soils DM of fodder fields, crop fields, and grassland was 10.25, 10.58, and 10.20 mg/kg, respectively. It was observed that protein-rich feeds had lower levels of arsenic accumulation (p < 0.048), while fiber-rich feeds containing more cellulose, hemicellulose, and lignin had higher arsenic levels (p < 0.017). Goats consumed 73.46% more arsenic per kg body weight compared to dairy cows. Although chronic and sub-chronic arsenic exposure in the district did not typically manifest symptoms or visible signs in ruminant animals, concentrations in the hair and feces of both cattle and goats exceeded normal values. Cattle feces had significantly higher arsenic (410.43 µg/kg DM) levels (p < 0.001) than goat feces (227.00 µg/kg DM), and arsenic concentration in cattle hair (1917.74 µg/kg DM) was also significantly greater (p < 0.001) than goat hair (1435.74 µg/kg DM). Arsenic levels in milk samples from both species were below 10 µg/kg. Liver (356.02 µg/kg DM) and kidney (317.22 µg/kg DM) contained significantly higher (p < 0.001) levels of arsenic compared to muscle (204.23 µg/kg DM), and bone (161.98 µg/kg DM) in local meat-type adult male goats. The skin accumulated the highest amount of arsenic (576.24 µg/kg DM) among the non-edible parts of the goat carcass. The cumulative cancer risk value for adults was 4.96 × 10, exceeding the threshold value (1 × 10). This suggests a significant risk of cancer development for the population in arsenic-affected areas. Non-cancer risks (hazard indexes) were estimated at 11.01 for adults. Our observations revealed that the highest bioaccumulation of arsenic occurred in the hair of cows, and goats in the examined localities. The biotransformation factor (BTF) for hair was much higher compared to other excreted samples from both species. The calculated BTF followed the order: hair > feces > milk for cows and goats. Livestock farmers in Nadia district are advised to carefully select feed resources, prioritizing those high in crude protein and low in neutral detergent fiber, and they should provide drinking water from deep aquifers to ensure the safety of milk and meat for human consumption.
本研究调查了印度西孟加拉邦纳迪亚地区不同环境成分中的砷(As)浓度及其对当地居民健康风险的潜在影响。该地区 40 名牲畜养殖户中随机抽取了 182 头牛和 255 只山羊,结果显示,动物和人类均通过受污染的饮用水、食物、草料、浓缩饲料、各种饲料树的叶子以及其他食物/饲料资源摄入了高浓度的砷。粗饲料中的砷浓度均值(483.18μg/kg DM)明显高于(p<0.001)树叶(391.53μg/kg DM)和浓缩饲料/成分(186.66μg/kg DM)。池塘水中的砷含量较高(106.11μg/L),浅管井水中的砷含量(47.96μg/L)和深管井水/自来水(10.64μg/L 和 10.04μg/L)较低。饲料田、农田和草地土壤 DM 的砷浓度均值分别为 10.25、10.58 和 10.20mg/kg。研究发现,蛋白质丰富的饲料砷积累水平较低(p<0.048),而富含纤维素、半纤维素和木质素的纤维丰富的饲料砷含量较高(p<0.017)。与奶牛相比,山羊每公斤体重摄入的砷多 73.46%。尽管该地区存在慢性和亚慢性砷暴露,但在反刍动物中并未出现明显的症状或可见迹象,牛和羊的毛发和粪便中的砷浓度均超过了正常值。牛粪便中的砷含量(410.43μg/kg DM)显著高于(p<0.001)羊粪便(227.00μg/kg DM),牛毛中的砷浓度(1917.74μg/kg DM)也显著高于(p<0.001)羊毛(1435.74μg/kg DM)。两种动物的奶样中砷含量均低于 10μg/kg。肝脏(356.02μg/kg DM)和肾脏(317.22μg/kg DM)中的砷含量显著高于(p<0.001)肌肉(204.23μg/kg DM)和骨骼(161.98μg/kg DM)中的含量,本地肉用雄性成年山羊。皮肤是羊体不可食用部分中砷含量最高的部位(576.24μg/kg DM)。成年人的累积癌症风险值为 4.96×10,超过了阈值(1×10)。这表明该地区人口存在患癌症的重大风险。非癌症风险(危害指数)估计为 11.01 岁。我们的观察结果表明,砷在牛和羊的毛发中的生物蓄积量最高。毛发的生物转化因子(BTF)远高于两种动物的其他排泄样本。计算出的 BTF 顺序为:牛和羊的毛发>粪便>奶。纳迪亚地区的牲畜养殖户应谨慎选择饲料资源,优先选择粗蛋白含量高、中性洗涤剂纤维含量低的饲料,并应提供来自深层蓄水层的饮用水,以确保牛奶和肉类供人类食用的安全性。