Microbial source tracking and identification of fecal contamination patterns in saltwater estuaries between base- and storm-flow events using dual genome-based approaches.

Fecal contamination from natural and anthropogenic sources poses significant threats to saltwater estuaries, particularly after storms or heavy rainfall. Monitoring fecal contamination is essential for protecting these vulnerable ecosystems having important ecological and economic values. In this study, we investigated the abundance, sources, and potential causes of fecal contamination at three marine and seven freshwater stations across Vaughn Bay (WA, USA), a shellfish growing district, during base- and storm-flow events. Additionally, we evaluated the performance of fecal indicator bacteria (FIB) quantification, optical brightener assessment, and qPCR analysis for fecal contamination quantification. We compared the effectiveness of qPCR-based microbial source tracking (MST), which targeted a broad range of hosts including, such as humans, birds, cows, horses, ruminants, dogs, and pigs, with sequencing-based MST in identifying fecal contamination sources. Both MST analysis approaches identified birds and humans as the primary sources of fecal contamination. For marine water stations, freshwater creeks VBU001, VBU002, and VB047, along with drain VB007, were identified as the main sources of human-derived fecal contamination in Vaughn Bay, based on Kendall's tau analysis (τ: 0.58-0.97). This information indicates that the septic systems in the catchment areas of these creeks and drains require further investigation to achieve effective fecal contamination control. Optical brightener, FIB enumeration and qPCR quantification results were generally higher during storm-flow events, although they showed poor correlation with each other (Pearson r < 0.40), likely due to physiological and phylogenetic differences among the target organisms of these methods. However, the sequencing-based method faces challenges in precise quantitative identification of differences in fecal contamination between base- and storm-flow events. Due to its high-throughput and cost-effectiveness, we recommend using sequencing-based analysis for large-scale identification of the primary sources of fecal contamination in water environments, followed by targeted qPCR quantification of MST markers for more precise assessments.