Jacobs Michael A, Jacobs Carly A, Intrator Orna, Makineni Rajesh, Youk Ada, Boudreaux-Kelly Monique Y, McCoy Jennifer L, Kinosian Bruce, Shireman Paula K, Hall Daniel E
Center for Health Equity Research and Promotion, VA Pittsburgh Healthcare System, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Geriatrics and Extended Care Data and Analysis Center, Canandaigua VA Medical Center, Canandaigua, New York.
JAMA Surg. 2025 Jan 1;160(1):56-64. doi: 10.1001/jamasurg.2024.4691.
Major surgery sometimes involves long recovery or even permanent institutionalization. Little is known about long-term trajectories of postoperative recovery, as surgical registries are limited to 30-day outcomes and care can occur across various institutions.
To characterize long-term postoperative recovery trajectories.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This retrospective cohort study used Veterans Affairs (VA) Surgical Quality Improvement Program data (2016 through 2019) linked to the Residential History File, combining data from the VA, Medicare/Medicaid, and other sources to capture most health care utilization by days. Patients were divided into younger (younger than 65 years) or older (65 years or older) subgroups, as Medicare eligibility is age dependent. Latent-class, group-based trajectory models were developed for each group. These data were analyzed from February 2023 through August 2024.
Surgical care in VA hospitals.
Days elsewhere than home (DEH) were counted in 30-day periods for 275 days presurgery and 365 days postsurgery.
A 5-trajectory solution was optimal and visually similar for both age groups (cases: 179 879 younger [mean age (SD) 51.2 (10.8) years; most were male [154 542 (83.0%)] and 198 803 older [mean (SD) age, 72.2 (6.0) years; 187 996 were male (97.6%)]). Most cases were in trajectories 1 and 2 (T1 and T2). T1 cases returned home within 30 days (younger, 74.0%; older, 54.2%), while T2 described delayed recovery within 30 to 60 days (younger, 21.6%; older, 35.5%). Trajectory 3 (T3) and trajectory 4 (T4) were similar for the first 30 days postsurgery, but subsequently separated with T3 representing protracted recovery of 6 months or longer (younger, 2.7%; older, 3.8%) and T4 indicating long-term loss of independence (younger, 1.3%; older, 5.2%). Few (trajectory 5) were chronically dependent, with 20 to 30 DEH per month before and after surgery (younger, 0.4%; older, 1.3%).
In this study, trajectory models demonstrated clinically meaningful differences in postoperative recovery that should inform surgical decision-making. Registries should include longer-term outcomes to enable future research to distinguish patients prone to long-term loss of independence vs protracted, but meaningful recovery.
大手术有时需要漫长的恢复过程,甚至可能导致永久性住院。由于手术登记仅限于30天的结果,且护理可能在不同机构进行,因此对术后恢复的长期轨迹了解甚少。
描述术后长期恢复轨迹。
设计、设置和参与者:这项回顾性队列研究使用了退伍军人事务部(VA)手术质量改进计划的数据(2016年至2019年),并与居住历史档案相链接,结合了VA、医疗保险/医疗补助和其他来源的数据,以按天数记录大多数医疗保健的使用情况。患者被分为较年轻(65岁以下)或较年长(65岁及以上)亚组,因为医疗保险资格取决于年龄。为每个组开发了基于潜在类别、基于群体的轨迹模型。这些数据于2023年2月至2024年8月进行分析。
VA医院的手术护理。
术前275天和术后365天按30天周期计算非在家天数(DEH)。
对于两个年龄组,5轨迹解决方案是最优的,且在视觉上相似(病例:179879名较年轻患者[平均年龄(标准差)51.2(10.8)岁;大多数为男性[154542名(83.0%)]和198803名较年长患者[平均(标准差)年龄72.2(6.0)岁;187996名男性(97.6%)])。大多数病例处于轨迹1和轨迹2(T1和T2)。T1病例在30天内回家(较年轻患者为74.0%;较年长患者为54.2%),而T2描述的是在30至60天内恢复延迟(较年轻患者为21.6%;较年长患者为35.5%)。术后前30天,轨迹3(T3)和轨迹4(T4)相似,但随后分开,T3代表6个月或更长时间的长期恢复(较年轻患者为2.7%;较年长患者为3.8%),T4表明长期丧失独立能力(较年轻患者为1.3%;较年长患者为5.2%)。很少有患者(轨迹5)长期依赖他人,术前和术后每月有20至30个DEH(较年轻患者为0.4%;较年长患者为1.3%)。
在本研究中,轨迹模型显示了术后恢复中具有临床意义的差异,这应为手术决策提供参考。登记系统应纳入长期结局,以便未来的研究能够区分易长期丧失独立能力的患者与长期但有意义恢复的患者。