Alanezi Tariq, Alomran Faris, Koussayer Samer, Abdulrahim Omer, Dahman Mohammed, Alsuhaibani Eyas, Alokaili Riyadh, Al-Omran Mohammed
College of Medicine, King Saud University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
Department of Surgery, King Faisal Specialist Hospital and Research Center, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
J Vasc Surg. 2025 Mar;81(3):665-671.e2. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2024.11.008. Epub 2024 Nov 16.
Carotid body tumors (CBTs) are rare neoplasms that pose significant surgical challenges. This study aims to evaluate the predictive utility of preoperative radiological characteristics on postoperative complications in patients undergoing CBT resection at a tertiary care center.
A retrospective analysis was conducted on 106 patients who underwent CBT resection between 2003 and 2023. Patient demographics, tumor characteristics, and operative details were collected. The primary outcomes were an estimated blood loss (EBL) >250 mL and cranial nerve (CN) injury. Logistic regression models were used to identify significant preoperative radiological predictors, including Shamblin grade, Peking Union Medical College Hospital (PUMCH) grade, tumor distance to the base of the skull (DTBOS), and tumor volume.
One hundred six patients were included. Higher Shamblin and PUMCH grades were significantly associated with increased EBL and CN injury. Specifically, the Shamblin grade alone predicted an EBL >250 mL with a McFadden R value of 0.14, which slightly decreased to 0.13 when DTBOS and tumor volume were added. For CN injury, the Shamblin grade alone had an R of 0.16, which significantly improved to 0.27 with the addition of DTBOS and further to 0.29 with tumor volume. The PUMCH grade alone predicted an EBL >250 mL with an R value of 0.08, which did not significantly change with the addition of DTBOS and tumor volume. For CN injury, the PUMCH grade alone had an R of 0.14, improving to 0.21 with DTBOS and to 0.22 with tumor volume. Furthermore, a 1-cm decrease in DTBOS significantly increased the odds of requiring a blood transfusion (odds ratio, 2.26; 95% confidence interval, 1.28-4.01; P = .0051) and the risk of CN injury (odds ratio, 3.65; 95% confidence interval, 1.98-6.73; P < .0001).
This study identified novel preoperative radiological predictors that enhance the predictive accuracy of standard classification systems, offering valuable insights for preoperative planning. Although the Shamblin and PUMCH classifications are useful tools on their own, our findings demonstrate that incorporating additional radiological features, such as DTBOS and tumor volume, can substantially increase their predictive utility. Surgeons are encouraged to incorporate multiple preoperative radiological variables alongside traditional classification systems to better assess the risk of postoperative complications. Further research with larger, multi-institutional cohorts are necessary to validate these findings and refine predictive models.
颈动脉体瘤(CBTs)是罕见肿瘤,给手术带来重大挑战。本研究旨在评估术前影像学特征对三级医疗中心接受CBT切除患者术后并发症的预测效用。
对2003年至2023年间接受CBT切除的106例患者进行回顾性分析。收集患者人口统计学资料、肿瘤特征和手术细节。主要结局为估计失血量(EBL)>250 mL和脑神经(CN)损伤。采用逻辑回归模型确定术前影像学显著预测因素,包括Shamblin分级、北京协和医院(PUMCH)分级、肿瘤至颅底距离(DTBOS)和肿瘤体积。
纳入106例患者。较高的Shamblin分级和PUMCH分级与EBL增加和CN损伤显著相关。具体而言,单独的Shamblin分级预测EBL>250 mL时McFadden R值为0.14,加入DTBOS和肿瘤体积后略降至0.13。对于CN损伤,单独的Shamblin分级R值为0.16,加入DTBOS后显著提高至0.27,加入肿瘤体积后进一步提高至0.29。单独的PUMCH分级预测EBL>250 mL时R值为0.0捌,加入DTBOS和肿瘤体积后无显著变化。对于CN损伤,单独的PUMCH分级R值为0.14,加入DTBOS后提高至0.21,加入肿瘤体积后提高至0.22。此外,DTBOS每减少1 cm,输血几率显著增加(优势比,2.26;95%置信区间,1.28 - 4.01;P = .0051),CN损伤风险增加(优势比,3.65;95%置信区间,1.98 - 6.73;P < .0001)。
本研究确定了新的术前影像学预测因素,提高了标准分类系统的预测准确性,为术前规划提供了有价值的见解。虽然Shamblin和PUMCH分类本身是有用的工具,但我们的研究结果表明,纳入额外的影像学特征,如DTBOS和肿瘤体积,可大幅提高其预测效用。鼓励外科医生在传统分类系统基础上纳入多个术前影像学变量,以更好地评估术后并发症风险。需要更大规模的多机构队列进一步研究来验证这些发现并完善预测模型。