Faculty of Dentistry, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China.
JDR Clin Trans Res. 2024 Oct;9(1_suppl):88S-98S. doi: 10.1177/23800844241273821.
"One health" is an integrated, unifying approach that recognizes the interconnectedness between the health of people, animals, and the environment. Oral diseases are the most common diseases to affect humankind, and it is increasingly acknowledged that key determinants of oral heath are social and environmental. However, there is a dearth of information on the relationship between oral health and one health.
A scoping review was conducted to examine how animal and environmental health affects human oral health and vice versa, to examine the interest in the field overtime, and to provide a synthesis of the literature concerning one health in the oral health context to date.
A broad standardized search strategy was employed across 5 electronic databases. Screening of publications with defined inclusion and exclusion criteria followed PRISMA-ScR (the Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews) guidelines.
The initial search yielded 345 articles; 163 remained after removal of duplicates. Nineteen articles were identified as "potentially effective studies," and after consideration of the full text, 13 articles were identified as "effective studies" to inform this review. Most studies were published since 2020 (60.5%, 8/13), and there were reports from 5 of the 6 World Health Organization regions (except the Eastern Mediterranean region). Most studies were observation in nature and mostly of cross-sectional study design (84.7%, 11/13 studies). More than half of the studies (53.8%, 7/13) were concerned with how environmental factors such as chemical exposures affect human oral health. Studies involving animals (46.2%, 6/13) highlighted the risk of zoonotic infections from horses and livestock to humans.
There is a recent and growing interest in "one health" in the oral health context. Qualitative synthesis of data highlighted the interconnectedness between the health of animals and environment with human health with implications for consideration and action by dentistry.
The results of this scoping review address the importance of dentistry in the "one health" concept. This scoping review will allow other researchers to be aware of and fill literature gaps with respect to the impact of animal health and environment on oral health and contribute to future research.
“One health” 是一种综合、统一的方法,它认识到人类、动物和环境的健康之间的相互联系。口腔疾病是最常见的影响人类的疾病,人们越来越认识到口腔健康的关键决定因素是社会和环境。然而,关于口腔健康与 One health 之间关系的信息却很少。
进行了范围综述,以检查动物和环境健康如何影响人类口腔健康,反之亦然,以检查该领域随时间的兴趣,并提供迄今为止关于口腔健康背景下 One health 的文献综述。
采用广泛的标准化搜索策略在 5 个电子数据库中进行。根据 PRISMA-ScR(系统评价和 Meta 分析扩展用于范围综述)指南对出版物进行筛选。
最初的搜索产生了 345 篇文章;去除重复项后,还剩 163 篇。19 篇文章被确定为“潜在有效研究”,在考虑全文后,有 13 篇文章被确定为“有效研究”,以提供本综述。大多数研究是在 2020 年之后发表的(60.5%,8/13),并且来自世界卫生组织 6 个区域中的 5 个区域(除了东地中海区域)有报告。大多数研究为观察性自然研究,且主要为横断面研究设计(84.7%,13 项研究中的 11 项)。超过一半的研究(53.8%,13 项研究中的 7 项)关注环境因素(如化学暴露)如何影响人类口腔健康。涉及动物的研究(46.2%,13 项研究中的 6 项)强调了马和家畜向人类传播人畜共患感染的风险。
在口腔健康背景下,对“One health”的兴趣最近有所增长。对数据的定性综合强调了动物和环境健康与人类健康之间的相互联系,这对口腔健康的考虑和行动具有重要意义。
本范围综述的结果强调了口腔健康概念中牙科的重要性。本范围综述将使其他研究人员能够了解并填补有关动物健康和环境对口腔健康影响的文献空白,并为未来的研究做出贡献。