Instructor, Oral Health Policy and Epidemiology, Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Boston, MA, USA.
Dental student, Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Boston, MA, USA.
JDR Clin Trans Res. 2024 Oct;9(1_suppl):70S-87S. doi: 10.1177/23800844241273775.
Adolescents have experienced increasing levels of anxiety (AD) and depressive disorders (DD) in recent years. This study assessed the current attitudes of pediatric dentists and orthodontists on incorporating screenings for mental health disorders for their adolescent patients.
A sequential mixed-methods approach was used. A 35-item survey was sent to 5,538 pediatric dentists and orthodontists that included questions about attitudes and current screening practices for AD and DD. Multivariate logistic regression analysis was performed to examine factors associated with dentists' willingness to incorporate screening and discuss results with patients for AD and DD. Subsequently, we interviewed 16 orthodontists and pediatric dentists, conducted thematic analysis, and identified themes and subthemes.
Based on 305 responses, >80% of respondents viewed screening for AD and DD as important, but <15% conducted screenings for them. Moreover, for those not screening, the odds of future screening for AD (odds ratio [OR]: 0.18, confidence interval [CI]: 0.08-0.43) and DD (OR: 0.23; CI: 0.09-0.56) were lower as the perceived importance of screening increased. Their willingness to screen for both AD (OR: 0.26, CI: 0.08-0.82) and DD (OR: 0.18, CI: 0.05-0.71) was also lower if they perceived this to negatively affect their patients' perception of them. The thematic analysis identified 3 main themes: (1) provider attitudes around mental health, (2) barriers to incorporating mental health screening, and (3) opportunities to integrate screening. Barriers included lack of training, access to mental health resources, and provider and patient stigma.
Our study showed that while most pediatric dentists and orthodontists understand the importance of screening their adolescent patients for AD and DD, many are unlikely to conduct screenings in the future. Obstacles such as inadequate training and stigma must be addressed for wider adoption. Further research and initiatives are crucial to tackle these challenges.
The findings of this study offer insights to clinicians and policy makers into the attitudes, barriers, and facilitators among dentists-specifically pediatric dentists and orthodontists-who regularly treat adolescent patients, regarding mental health screenings for these individuals. This information can guide the development of initiatives, policy changes, and future research aimed at creating a more integrated dental care system that emphasizes the overall health of adolescent patients.
近年来,青少年的焦虑症(AD)和抑郁症(DD)水平有所上升。本研究评估了儿科牙医和正畸医生对为青少年患者进行心理健康障碍筛查的当前态度。
采用序贯混合方法。向 5538 名儿科牙医和正畸医生发送了一份包含 AD 和 DD 态度和当前筛查实践问题的 35 项调查。采用多变量逻辑回归分析检查与牙医愿意进行筛查以及与患者讨论 AD 和 DD 结果相关的因素。随后,我们采访了 16 名正畸医生和儿科牙医,进行了主题分析,并确定了主题和子主题。
根据 305 份回复,超过 80%的受访者认为筛查 AD 和 DD 很重要,但<15%的受访者进行了筛查。此外,对于那些不进行筛查的人,随着筛查重要性的增加,未来筛查 AD(比值比[OR]:0.18,置信区间[CI]:0.08-0.43)和 DD(OR:0.23;CI:0.09-0.56)的可能性较低。如果他们认为这会影响患者对他们的看法,他们也不太愿意筛查 AD(OR:0.26,CI:0.08-0.82)和 DD(OR:0.18,CI:0.05-0.71)。主题分析确定了 3 个主要主题:(1)提供者对心理健康的态度,(2)纳入心理健康筛查的障碍,(3)整合筛查的机会。障碍包括缺乏培训、获取心理健康资源、提供者和患者的耻辱感。
我们的研究表明,虽然大多数儿科牙医和正畸医生了解对青少年患者进行 AD 和 DD 筛查的重要性,但许多人未来不太可能进行筛查。必须解决培训不足、污名化等障碍,以实现更广泛的采用。进一步的研究和举措对于应对这些挑战至关重要。
本研究的结果为临床医生和政策制定者提供了有关经常治疗青少年患者的牙医(尤其是儿科牙医和正畸医生)对这些人进行心理健康筛查的态度、障碍和促进因素的见解。这些信息可以指导制定旨在创建更注重青少年患者整体健康的综合牙科护理系统的举措、政策变化和未来研究。