Maragha Tala, Perez-Garcia Arnaldo, Shuler Charles, Walker Judith, von Bergmann HsingChi
Department of Oral Health Sciences, Faculty of Dentistry, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
Department of Dentistry, Faculty of Medicine & Dentistry, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
J Dent Educ. 2025 Jun;89(6):903-912. doi: 10.1002/jdd.13778. Epub 2024 Nov 20.
Preclinical dental education can challenge students' wellbeing. These challenges are multifaceted and are experienced differently across student populations. However, an in-depth understanding of these challenges and the changes in the students' response to them remains limited. Therefore, this study aims to explore the wellbeing experiences of preclinical dental students and the strategies they developed to maintain their wellbeing over two time points: the academic years 2021/2022 and 2012/2013.
A case study was conducted using qualitative data from semi-structured interviews with preclinical dental students in 2021/2022. Data were thematically analyzed, and data from the Dental Student Study Habits Survey in 2012/2013 were later used for triangulation.
Fifteen students participated in the interviews. Twenty-four students participated in the 2012/2013 survey in the beginning of the academic year. Three themes emerged-uncertain transitions, challenging interactions, and multifaceted impact and balancing strategies-along with various subthemes. Students in 2012/3013 reported high levels of stress, anxiety, overwhelm, and fatigue during dental school in comparison with other time points, and most students in both periods reported developing physical, phycological, and social strategies to maintain their wellbeing. The lack of time was found to be a barrier for practicing stress management strategies across the two time points.
Students experience several challenges in preclinical dental education that negatively impacts their wellbeing and seem to persist over the past decade. It is important that dental education programs consider inclusive and nurturing teaching approaches in the learning environment to support students' wellbeing and performance.
临床前牙科教育可能会对学生的幸福感构成挑战。这些挑战是多方面的,不同学生群体的体验也有所不同。然而,对这些挑战以及学生对其反应的变化的深入理解仍然有限。因此,本研究旨在探讨临床前牙科学生的幸福感体验以及他们在两个时间点(2021/2022学年和2012/2013学年)制定的维持幸福感的策略。
采用定性数据进行案例研究,这些数据来自2021/2022年对临床前牙科学生的半结构化访谈。对数据进行了主题分析,2012/2013年牙科学生学习习惯调查的数据随后用于三角验证。
15名学生参与了访谈。24名学生在学年开始时参加了2012/2013年的调查。出现了三个主题——不确定的过渡、具有挑战性的互动以及多方面的影响和平衡策略——以及各种子主题。与其他时间点相比,2012/3013年的学生在牙科学习期间报告了高水平的压力、焦虑、不知所措和疲劳,两个时期的大多数学生都报告制定了身体、心理和社交策略来维持他们的幸福感。发现时间不足是在两个时间点实施压力管理策略的障碍。
学生在临床前牙科教育中经历了几个挑战,这些挑战对他们的幸福感产生了负面影响,并且似乎在过去十年中一直存在。牙科教育项目在学习环境中考虑采用包容性和培养性的教学方法以支持学生的幸福感和表现非常重要。