Boroumand Sam, Stogniy Sasha, Katsnelson Beatrice, Allam Omar, Zahedi Vafa Aliyar, Sullivan Janessa, Pomahac Bohdan, Haykal Siba, Butler Paris D
From the Division of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Department of Surgery, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, Conn.
Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open. 2024 Nov 26;12(11):e6286. doi: 10.1097/GOX.0000000000006286. eCollection 2024 Nov.
Subspecialty fellowship directors are essential to the selection and mentorship of trainees. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the gender and racial/ethnic diversity of fellowship directors across fellowship programs in plastic and reconstructive surgery (PRS).
In December 2023, listings of fellowship programs/directors were surveyed from respective professional society websites across the 5 primary PRS fellowships: hand (American Society for Surgery of the Hand), craniofacial (American Society of Craniofacial Surgeons), microsurgery (American Society for Reconstructive Microsurgery), aesthetic (The Aesthetic Society), and burn (American Burn Association). Fellowship director demographics from each program were researched and identified.
In total, 248 fellowship directors were identified: 94 hand, 34 craniofacial, 62 microsurgery, 38 aesthetic, and 20 burn. There was a significantly greater percentage of male versus female directors across all fellowships (87.5% versus 12.5%; < 0.01). Men were noted to have a significantly higher average h-index score (20.4 versus 15.0; = 0.045) but constituted a lower proportion of assistant professorships (32.3% versus 12.9%; < 0.01). Relative to directors from racial/ethnic minority backgrounds, White directors constituted a significantly greater percentage of fellowship directors (72.9% versus 27.1%; < 0.01) and had a greater number of years passed since completing their most recent training (21.7 versus 17.1; = 0.030).
Across PRS fellowship programs, women and racial/ethnic minorities are disproportionately underrepresented in leadership. Targeted initiatives to promote diversity in PRS fellowship directors should be considered as medicine works toward a surgical workforce more reflective of the patient population.
专科 fellowship 主任对于学员的选拔和指导至关重要。本研究的目的是评估整形外科(PRS)各 fellowship 项目中 fellowship 主任的性别和种族/民族多样性。
2023 年 12 月,从 5 个主要的 PRS fellowship 项目(手外科,美国手外科协会;颅面外科,美国颅面外科医师协会;显微外科,美国重建显微外科学会;美容外科,美容外科学会;烧伤外科,美国烧伤协会)各自的专业协会网站上调查了 fellowship 项目/主任的列表。研究并确定了每个项目中 fellowship 主任的人口统计学信息。
总共确定了 248 名 fellowship 主任:94 名手外科、34 名颅面外科、62 名显微外科、38 名美容外科和 20 名烧伤外科。在所有 fellowship 项目中,男性主任的比例明显高于女性(87.5%对 12.5%;<0.01)。男性的平均 h 指数得分明显更高(20.4 对 15.0;=0.045),但担任助理教授职位的比例较低(32.3%对 12.9%;<0.01)。相对于来自种族/民族少数群体背景的主任,白人主任在 fellowship 主任中所占比例明显更高(72.9%对 27.1%;<0.01),并且自完成最近一次培训以来的年数更多(21.7 对 17.1;=0.030)。
在 PRS fellowship 项目中,女性和种族/民族少数群体在领导层中的代表性严重不足。随着医学朝着建立一支更能反映患者群体的外科劳动力队伍发展,应考虑采取有针对性的举措来促进 PRS fellowship 主任的多样性。