Chuang Emmeline, Ross Rachel, Safaeinili Nadia, Haley Leigh Ann, O'Masta Brenna, Pourat Nadereh
School of Social Welfare, University of California Berkeley, Berkeley, California, USA.
School of Medicine, Stanford University, Stanford, California, USA.
Health Serv Res. 2025 May;60 Suppl 3(Suppl 3):e14417. doi: 10.1111/1475-6773.14417. Epub 2024 Dec 4.
To identify collaboration strategies used to integrate health, behavioral health, and social services for Medicaid members in California's Medi-Cal Whole Person Care Pilot program (WPC).
WPC was a social care intervention implemented to identify and address eligible members' health, behavioral health, and social needs. Data included semi-structured key informant interviews conducted in 2018-2019 (n = 221) and 2021 (n = 167); pilot-level surveys; whole-network surveys of 507 organizations in all 25 pilots participating in WPC; and documents submitted by pilots to the state. Pilots served a total of 247,887 unique members between 2017 and 2021, the majority of whom were non-white (72%) and over half of whom experienced homelessness.
STUDY DESIGN/DATA COLLECTION: Data were collected as part of the statewide evaluation of WPC. We analyzed qualitative data to examine strategies used by pilots to integrate care, network data to identify pilots that improved cross-sector collaboration (i.e., strengthened density or multiplexity of cross-sector ties) following WPC implementation, and comparative case analysis to identify strategies that differentiated pilots that improved collaboration from those that did not.
Pilots used multiple strategies to facilitate the integration of care. Network analyses identified 10 pilots that significantly improved either density or multiplexity of cross-sector ties, and one pilot with high cross-sector collaboration prior to WPC. Compared to pilots that did not improve cross-sector collaboration, these pilots meaningfully engaged partners in program design and implementation, used braided funds, and leveraged WPC to support broader systems change. These pilots also reported fewer challenges in developing and managing contractual relationships and ensuring meaningful use of data-sharing infrastructure by frontline staff responsible for care coordination.
Data sharing is necessary but not sufficient for systems alignment. Collaboration strategies focused on addressing financial barriers to integration and strengthening normative and interpersonal integration are also needed.
确定在加利福尼亚州医疗补助全人护理试点项目(WPC)中,用于整合医疗、行为健康和社会服务以惠及医疗补助受益人的合作策略。
WPC是一项社会护理干预措施,旨在识别并满足符合条件的受益人的医疗、行为健康和社会需求。数据包括2018 - 2019年(n = 221)和2021年(n = 167)进行的半结构化关键信息提供者访谈;试点层面的调查;对参与WPC的所有25个试点中的507个组织进行的全网络调查;以及试点向该州提交的文件。2017年至2021年期间,试点共服务了247,887名不同的受益人,其中大多数是非白人(72%),超过半数曾经历无家可归。
研究设计/数据收集:作为对WPC进行的全州评估的一部分收集数据。我们分析定性数据以研究试点用于整合护理的策略,分析网络数据以识别在WPC实施后改善跨部门合作(即加强跨部门联系的密度或多重性)的试点,并通过比较案例分析来确定能区分改善合作的试点与未改善合作的试点的策略。
试点采用了多种策略来促进护理整合。网络分析确定了10个显著提高跨部门联系密度或多重性的试点,以及一个在WPC之前就有高度跨部门合作的试点。与未改善跨部门合作的试点相比,这些试点让合作伙伴切实参与项目设计和实施,使用混合资金,并利用WPC支持更广泛的系统变革。这些试点还报告称,在建立和管理合同关系以及确保负责护理协调的一线工作人员有效使用数据共享基础设施方面面临的挑战较少。
数据共享对于系统整合是必要的,但并不充分。还需要专注于消除整合的财务障碍以及加强规范和人际整合的合作策略。