Degefa Ketema, Aliyi Mohammad, Ackley Caroline, Damise Berhanu, Wakwaya Getahun, Madrid Lola, Assefa Nega, Seale Anna, Tadesse Adugna, Sintayehu Bizunesh, Zegeye Yosef, Girma Zerihun, Asfaw Yenenesh Tilahun, Feyissa Gurmu, Yigzaw Hiwot, Taye Eyoel, Asnake Kidist, Tadesse Simegn, Alemu Addisu, Sarkodie-Mensah Nana, Kone Ahoua, Maixenchs Maria, Blevins John, Breines Markus
College of Health and Medical Sciences, Haramaya University, Harar, Ethiopia.
Brighton and Sussex Medical School, Brighton, UK.
BMC Public Health. 2024 Dec 26;24(1):3589. doi: 10.1186/s12889-024-21164-7.
It is crucial to consider cultural, religious, and socio-behavioural factors that may influence the acceptability of Minimally Invasive Tissues Sampling (MITS). MITS is being used to understand the causes of child death and conducted in nine countries within Africa and South Asia with the highest child mortality. Progress has been made in the development of laboratory infrastructures and training for physicians to do MITS, but many communities are concerned about the religious acceptability of taking samples from deceased children. This paper explores the acceptability of MITS in a predominantly Muslim community.
A qualitative study was conducted in Kersa and Harar, in Eastern Ethiopia between April 23, 2018 and April 21, 2019 where high child mortality rates have been recorded. The study involved interviews and focus groups with 76 participants, including mothers, elders, and religious leaders. In addition, observations were conducted at burial ceremonies and in grieving families' homes. Grounded theory framework is used in this article to understand the acceptability of postmortem MITS.
We explore cultural, religious, and socio-behavioural barriers and facilitators that may influence the acceptability of minimally invasive tissue sampling. We identify three themes relating to the acceptability of MITS: (1) Perceptions and rituals related to child death (2), Religious acceptance of post-mortem investigation, and (3) Fears and suspicions of organ theft and body mutilation. Most participants hypothetically accepted MITS, but suggested that the procedure consider religious practices. Religious leaders and parents stated that they would accept the procedure if it would help reduce child deaths. Acceptance is inconsistent and differs across time and place. Some villages accepted the procedure swiftly, only to change their views when they became aware of suspicions from other villages about the procedure disfiguring the body. Parents of deceased children were concerned that taking samples from the children's bodies would delay the burial.
Mortality surveillance requires a thorough understanding of the cultural, religious, and sociocultural aspects that may affect the acceptability of MITS. MITS research should be conducted close to communities, involving community members, incorporating religious perspectives, and promoting health outreach campaigns to facilitate sociocultural perceptions of the research activities.
考虑可能影响微创组织采样(MITS)可接受性的文化、宗教和社会行为因素至关重要。MITS正被用于了解儿童死亡原因,并在非洲和南亚儿童死亡率最高的九个国家开展。在实验室基础设施建设以及培训医生进行MITS方面已取得进展,但许多社区对从已故儿童身上采样的宗教可接受性表示担忧。本文探讨了MITS在一个主要为穆斯林的社区中的可接受性。
2018年4月23日至2019年4月21日期间,在埃塞俄比亚东部的克尔萨和哈勒尔进行了一项定性研究,当地记录了较高的儿童死亡率。该研究包括对76名参与者进行访谈和焦点小组讨论,参与者包括母亲、长辈和宗教领袖。此外,还在葬礼仪式和悲痛家庭的家中进行了观察。本文采用扎根理论框架来理解死后MITS的可接受性。
我们探讨了可能影响微创组织采样可接受性的文化、宗教和社会行为障碍及促进因素。我们确定了与MITS可接受性相关的三个主题:(1)与儿童死亡相关的认知和仪式;(2)对死后调查的宗教接受度;(3)对器官盗窃和身体残害的恐惧与怀疑。大多数参与者在假设情况下接受MITS,但建议该程序应考虑宗教习俗。宗教领袖和家长表示,如果该程序有助于减少儿童死亡,他们会接受。接受情况不一致,且随时间和地点而不同。一些村庄迅速接受了该程序,但当他们意识到其他村庄对该程序会损毁尸体的怀疑时,就改变了看法。已故儿童的家长担心从孩子尸体上采样会延迟葬礼。
死亡率监测需要全面了解可能影响MITS可接受性的文化、宗教和社会文化方面。MITS研究应在社区附近开展,让社区成员参与,纳入宗教观点,并开展健康宣传活动,以促进社区对研究活动的社会文化认知。