West Kirstin, Pauley Alena, Buono Mia, Mikindo Miriana, Sawe Yvonne, Kilasara Joseph, Sakita Francis, Rent Sharla, Mchome Bariki, Mmbaga Blandina T, Staton Catherine A
Duke Global Health Institute, Duke University, Durham, North Carolina, United States of America.
Kilimanjaro Clinical Research Institute, Moshi, Tanzania.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2024 Dec 30;4(12):e0003681. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0003681. eCollection 2024.
Rates of prenatal alcohol use in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) are increasing despite regulatory bodies urging pregnant women to abstain from alcohol. Tanzania has minimal policies, interventions, and educational programs addressing prenatal alcohol exposure. Consequently, a considerable number of mothers and their fetuses are exposed to alcohol, leading to serious health consequences like fetal alcohol spectrum disorder (FASD). Our study aims to understand the alcohol use practices of pregnant women, the knowledge and attitudes related to prenatal alcohol exposure among different genders and generations, and how these may be influenced by community perceptions and cultural beliefs among patients at Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Center (KCMC).
A total of 676 individuals seeking care at the KCMC Emergency Department (ED) or Reproductive Health Center (RHC) met our inclusion criteria, were approached for participation using a systematic random sampling method, and were enrolled. Of those, 541 women and 114 men completed the survey. The quantitative analysis focused exclusively on survey data from 533 women who reported their pregnancy status and age. Descriptive frequencies were used to compare sociodemographic factors and alcohol use practices across three female groups stratified by pregnancy status and age. Nineteen survey participants-both men and women-were purposively selected for qualitative semi-structured in-depth interviews (IDIs) exploring knowledge, attitudes, and cultural beliefs surrounding alcohol use during pregnancy. A grounded theory approach was used to analyze IDIs in NVivo.
A large percentage of pregnant women reported consuming alcohol at least once per week (42.2%). Older non-pregnant women exhibited the highest rate of alcohol use per week (66.0%). Many older non-pregnant women (28.7%) perceived alcohol use as acceptable during pregnancy. Younger non-pregnant women had the highest prevalence of harmful or hazardous drinking (HHD) at 16.4%. This group also reported the highest weekly alcohol expenses, with 18.1% spending over 10,000 Tanzanian shillings (TZS) per week. Median [IQR] DrInC scores were 0 [0-0] for pregnant women, 0 [0-7] for younger non-pregnant women, and 0 [0-1] for older non-pregnant women. Older non-pregnant women exhibited the highest prevalence of depression (31.4%). Median [IQR] PHQ-9 scores were 4 [3-6.25] for pregnant women, 5 [2-8] for younger non-pregnant women, and 6 [3-10] for older non-pregnant women. Qualitative analyses demonstrated that (1) cultural beliefs are intricately tied to perceived benefits of prenatal alcohol exposure, (2) a history of alcohol use preceding pregnancy largely influences prenatal alcohol use, and (3) community views of PWCA are negative.
Our findings demonstrate high rates of prenatal alcohol use in Moshi, Tanzania, with pre-pregnancy alcohol use as a significant predictor. Despite generally negative views of pregnant women who consume alcohol (PWCA), some sociocultural beliefs and limited knowledge about the dangers of prenatal alcohol exposure encouraged alcohol use during pregnancy. To improve health outcomes and reduce alcohol-related pregnancy complications for current and future generations, community-wide health messaging and pre-pregnancy interventions may prove beneficial for pregnant women and women of reproductive age who consume alcohol.
尽管监管机构敦促孕妇戒酒,但撒哈拉以南非洲地区(SSA)的产前酒精使用比率仍在上升。坦桑尼亚针对产前酒精暴露的政策、干预措施和教育项目极少。因此,相当数量的母亲及其胎儿暴露于酒精中,导致诸如胎儿酒精谱系障碍(FASD)等严重健康后果。我们的研究旨在了解孕妇的酒精使用习惯、不同性别和代际对产前酒精暴露的知识和态度,以及这些因素如何受到乞力马扎罗基督教医疗中心(KCMC)患者的社区认知和文化信仰的影响。
共有676名在KCMC急诊科(ED)或生殖健康中心(RHC)寻求治疗的人符合我们的纳入标准,采用系统随机抽样方法邀请他们参与研究并进行登记。其中,541名女性和114名男性完成了调查。定量分析仅关注533名报告了怀孕状况和年龄的女性的调查数据。描述性频率用于比较按怀孕状况和年龄分层的三个女性群体的社会人口学因素和酒精使用习惯。特意从19名调查参与者(包括男性和女性)中选取进行定性半结构化深入访谈(IDI),以探讨围绕孕期酒精使用的知识、态度和文化信仰。采用扎根理论方法在NVivo中分析IDI。
很大比例的孕妇报告每周至少饮酒一次(42.2%)。年龄较大的非孕妇每周酒精使用率最高(66.0%)。许多年龄较大的非孕妇(28.7%)认为孕期饮酒是可以接受的。年龄较小的非孕妇有害或危险饮酒(HHD)患病率最高,为16.4%。该群体还报告每周酒精支出最高,18.1%的人每周花费超过10,000坦桑尼亚先令(TZS)。孕妇的DrInC评分中位数[四分位间距]为0[0 - 0],年龄较小的非孕妇为0[0 - 7],年龄较大的非孕妇为0[0 - 1]。年龄较大的非孕妇抑郁症患病率最高(31.4%)。孕妇的PHQ - 9评分中位数[四分位间距]为4[3 - 6.25],年龄较小的非孕妇为5[2 - 8],年龄较大的非孕妇为6[3 - 10]。定性分析表明:(1)文化信仰与产前酒精暴露的感知益处紧密相连;(2)怀孕前的饮酒史在很大程度上影响产前酒精使用;(3)社区对孕期饮酒妇女(PWCA)的看法是负面的。
我们的研究结果表明,坦桑尼亚莫希的产前酒精使用率很高,怀孕前饮酒是一个重要的预测因素。尽管人们普遍对饮酒的孕妇(PWCA)看法负面,但一些社会文化信仰以及对产前酒精暴露危害的有限了解促使了孕期饮酒行为。为改善健康结果并减少当前和未来几代人与酒精相关的妊娠并发症,全社区的健康宣传和孕前干预措施可能对饮酒的孕妇和育龄妇女有益。