Haycox W Connor, Tumin Dmitry
Department of Family Medicine, Brody School of Medicine, East Carolina University, Greenville, NC.
Department of Academic Affairs, Brody School of Medicine, East Carolina University, Greenville, NC.
Fam Med. 2025 Feb;57(2):77-82. doi: 10.22454/FamMed.2024.967125. Epub 2024 Dec 5.
Medical trainees express difficulty with interpreting statistics in clinical literature. To elucidate educational gaps, we compared statistical methodologies in biomedical literature with biostatistical content in licensing exam study materials.
In this bibliographic content analysis, we compiled a stratified random sample of articles involving original data analysis published during 2023 in 72 issues of three major medical journals. We recorded all discrete statistical methods and concepts detailed in the methods section of the articles and in three commercial licensing exam study resources. We created a unified list of discrete methods or concepts to define overarching domains and mapped each method to a domain to determine that domain's presence in each resource or article.
In a sample of 273 journal articles and three study resources, we identified 1,057 unique key words mapped onto 20 domains. Statistical error, significance, power analysis, and group comparisons of categorical data were high-frequency domains among the articles. Overall, 63% of articles included methods from domains not covered in any study resource.
Medical licensing exam preparation does not reflect the breadth of contemporary statistics in biomedical research. Future interventions should expand medical students' understanding of research protocols and complex data manipulation.
医学实习生表示在解读临床文献中的统计数据时存在困难。为了阐明教育差距,我们将生物医学文献中的统计方法与执照考试学习材料中的生物统计学内容进行了比较。
在这项文献内容分析中,我们编制了一个分层随机样本,样本包括2023年期间在三大医学期刊的72期上发表的涉及原始数据分析的文章。我们记录了文章方法部分以及三种商业执照考试学习资源中详细阐述的所有离散统计方法和概念。我们创建了一个离散方法或概念的统一列表,以定义总体领域,并将每种方法映射到一个领域,以确定该领域在每种资源或文章中的存在情况。
在273篇期刊文章和三种学习资源的样本中,我们识别出1057个独特的关键词,这些关键词映射到20个领域。统计误差、显著性、功效分析以及分类数据的组间比较是文章中的高频领域。总体而言,63%的文章包含了任何学习资源中未涵盖领域的方法。
医学执照考试的备考内容未能反映生物医学研究中当代统计学的广度。未来的干预措施应拓展医学生对研究方案和复杂数据操作的理解。