Broomhead Tom, Watt Samantha, El-Yousfi Sarab, Gray-Burrows Kara A, El Shuwihdi Hanin, Hudson Kristian, Day Peter F, Marshman Zoe
School of Clinical Dentistry, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, United Kingdom.
School of Dentistry, University of Leeds, Leeds, United Kingdom.
Br Dent J. 2025 Jan 17. doi: 10.1038/s41415-024-7782-0.
Introduction Supervised toothbrushing programmes (STPs) in nurseries and schools are effective at reducing inequalities in caries when targeted to areas of dental disease. Recent changes to government education and health policy have increased interest in STPs in England. This study aimed to establish the current level of provision of STPs in England, describe changes over time, understand associations with predictor variables, and summarise key barriers and facilitators to their implementation.Methods A national survey was conducted at upper tier local authority level about the extent of a STP across England between December 2023 and April 2024. Quantitative data were analysed using descriptive statistics, with regression analyses examining associations with key predictor variables. Barriers and facilitators to implementation were analysed and summarised based on the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research.Results Data were received from 152 local authorities. Around 60% implemented a STP. Nearly one-third of programmes were commissioned by local authorities (28.9%) and most adopted a targeted approach (77.8%). Statistical analyses demonstrated significant and positive associations between dental caries prevalence and the number of children in STPs. Barriers to implementation included: 1) funding; 2) capacity; 3) pressures at settings; 4) logistics; and 5) lack of engagement. Facilitators included: 1) partnerships and connections; 2) available resources; 3) oral health expertise; 4) external policy and incentives; 5) shared knowledge; and 6) engagement.Conclusions Provision of STPs in England has increased since 2022. Any future expansion of STPs should consider the barriers and facilitators identified to enable smooth implementation.
针对牙科疾病高发地区,在托儿所和学校开展的监督性刷牙计划(STP)能有效减少龋齿方面的不平等现象。英国政府教育和卫生政策的近期变化引发了对监督性刷牙计划的更多关注。本研究旨在确定英国目前监督性刷牙计划的实施水平,描述其随时间的变化,了解与预测变量的关联,并总结实施过程中的主要障碍和促进因素。
2023年12月至2024年4月期间,在英国高层地方当局层面进行了一项全国性调查,以了解监督性刷牙计划在英国的实施范围。定量数据采用描述性统计进行分析,回归分析则用于检验与关键预测变量的关联。基于实施研究综合框架,对实施过程中的障碍和促进因素进行了分析和总结。
收到了来自152个地方当局的数据。约60%实施了监督性刷牙计划。近三分之一的计划由地方当局委托实施(28.9%),大多数采用了针对性方法(77.8%)。统计分析表明,龋齿患病率与参与监督性刷牙计划的儿童数量之间存在显著正相关。实施障碍包括:1)资金;2)能力;3)场所压力;4)后勤;5)缺乏参与度。促进因素包括:1)伙伴关系和联系;2)可用资源;3)口腔健康专业知识;4)外部政策和激励措施;5)共享知识;6)参与度。
自2022年以来英国监督性刷牙计划的实施有所增加。未来监督性刷牙计划的任何扩展都应考虑已确定的障碍和促进因素以确保顺利实施。