Main Caitlin, Schäfer Cathrin, Kanavos Panos
Department of Health Policy and Medical Technology Research Group, LSE Health, London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK.
BeiGene, Basel, Switzerland.
Pharmacoecon Open. 2025 May;9(3):331-339. doi: 10.1007/s41669-024-00556-w. Epub 2025 Jan 25.
Disparities in access to oncology medicines in European Union (EU) member states can impact patient outcomes profoundly, with availability and timely access varying significantly across and within member states. This paper discusses the intersection of the new European Health Technology Assessment Regulation (HTAR), the provisions of the proposed pharmaceutical legislation and their potential impacts on access to oncology medicines across EU member states. The HTAR, seeking to standardise the clinical evaluation of new medicines, has the potential to streamline the evaluation process but also risks oversimplifying diverse national healthcare needs. While the HTAR may accelerate access in countries with less-developed health technology assessment systems, it could potentially conflict with established practices in countries with advanced assessment systems, resulting in both joint and national clinical evaluations becoming necessary. The proposed pharmaceutical legislation reform, in both initial and updated forms, aims to incentivise an EU-wide launch of new medicines that challenges the feasibility for manufacturers, particularly in the context of diverse and complex national pricing and reimbursement systems. Both initiatives mark a significant shift towards more collaborative European healthcare policy yet faces the potential of unintended consequences owing to an apparent lack of pragmatism, such as delays in access because of increased administrative burdens and possible deterrents for innovation in Europe. The paper underscores the need for policy adaptation and multi-stakeholder collaboration to ensure the legislative changes achieve equitable and timely access to oncology treatments across the EU.
欧盟成员国在肿瘤药物获取方面的差异会对患者治疗结果产生深远影响,各成员国之间以及成员国国内的药物可及性和及时获取情况差异显著。本文讨论了新的欧洲卫生技术评估法规(HTAR)、拟议的药品立法条款及其对欧盟成员国肿瘤药物获取的潜在影响。HTAR旨在规范新药的临床评估,有可能简化评估流程,但也存在过度简化各国不同医疗需求的风险。虽然HTAR可能会加快卫生技术评估体系欠发达国家的药物获取速度,但它可能会与评估体系先进国家的既定做法产生冲突,导致联合临床评估和国家临床评估都变得必要。拟议的药品立法改革,无论是初始形式还是更新形式,都旨在激励新药在全欧盟范围内推出,这对制药商的可行性提出了挑战,尤其是在各国定价和报销体系多样且复杂的情况下。这两项举措标志着欧洲医疗政策向更具协作性的方向发生了重大转变,但由于明显缺乏务实精神,可能会产生意想不到的后果,比如行政负担增加导致药物获取延迟,以及可能对欧洲的创新形成阻碍。本文强调需要进行政策调整和多利益相关方合作,以确保立法变革能让欧盟各国公平、及时地获取肿瘤治疗药物。