Nataf François, Scher Nathaniel, Bollet Marc, Mulier Guillaume, Birladeanu Andrei, Sopanda Lucian, Lambert Jérôme, Bouilhol Gauthier, Guey Stéphanie, Adle-Biassette Homa, Bernat Anne-Laure, Abbritti Rosaria, Passeri Thibault, Mandonnet Emmanuel, Froelich Sébastien
Department of Neurosurgery, Lariboisière Hospital, Paris, France.
CERVCO: Centre de Reference Des Maladies Rares du Cerveau Et de L'oeil, Paris, France.
Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2025 Feb 1;167(1):29. doi: 10.1007/s00701-024-06409-z.
Cavernous malformations (CM) of the brain are vascular abnormalities that carry a risk of bleeding, posing significant neurological and life-threatening challenges, particularly in posterior fossa. The efficacy of radiosurgery for cavernomas still remains a matter of debate, largely due to technical and statistical limitations. In this study, we present a series of posterior fossa cavernomas treated using CyberKnife radiosurgery, employing an innovative approach that integrates both technical and statistical advancements.
We conducted a prospective series involving 35 posterior fossa cavernomas in 33 patients treated with low-dose radiosurgery protocols (12 Gy in a single fraction or 18 Gy in 3 fractions). Compared to previously published series, our approach targeted a larger treatment volume, encompassing the entire hemosiderin ring surrounding the cavernoma. Radiosurgery was indicated for cases of hemorrhage or progressive neurological deficits in anatomically challenging, nonsurgical areas. The statistical analysis was designed to address the unknown onset time of cavernoma prior to radiosurgery, enabling a more accurate calculation of the hemorrhage incidence rate before treatment. Follow-up evaluations, including clinical assessments and MRI, were conducted at 3-6-9-12-18-24 months and subsequently on an annual basis.
With a mean follow-up duration of 26 months, exceeding the previously described latency period, and a median [IQR] follow-up of 13 months [8.7-30.4] which represents approximately half the latency period, only one patient experienced a recurrence of hemorrhage, occurring 20 months post-treatment and remaining asymptomatic. No patients exhibited radio-induced parenchymal changes or clinical deterioration following radiosurgery.
These preliminary results support the strategy of increasing the target volume while reducing the radiation dose for cavernous malformations. We further recommend incorporating sensitivity analyses to evaluate the robustness of results, particularly in the context of uncertainties surrounding the time of onset of cavernomas.
脑海绵状畸形(CM)是一种血管异常疾病,存在出血风险,会带来重大的神经学和危及生命的挑战,尤其是在后颅窝。放射外科治疗海绵状血管瘤的疗效仍存在争议,这主要是由于技术和统计方面的局限性。在本研究中,我们展示了一系列使用射波刀放射外科治疗的后颅窝海绵状畸形病例,采用了一种整合了技术和统计进展的创新方法。
我们进行了一项前瞻性研究,涉及33例患者的35个后颅窝海绵状畸形,采用低剂量放射外科方案(单次分割12 Gy或3次分割18 Gy)进行治疗。与先前发表的系列研究相比,我们的方法针对更大的治疗体积,包括海绵状畸形周围的整个含铁血黄素环。对于解剖结构复杂、无法手术区域出现出血或进行性神经功能缺损的病例,采用放射外科治疗。统计分析旨在解决放射外科治疗前海绵状畸形未知的发病时间问题,从而更准确地计算治疗前的出血发生率。随访评估包括临床评估和MRI,在3、6、9、12、18、24个月时进行,随后每年进行一次。
平均随访时间为26个月,超过了先前描述的潜伏期,中位随访时间[四分位间距]为13个月[8.7 - 30.4],约为潜伏期的一半,只有1例患者在治疗后20个月出现出血复发,且仍无症状。放射外科治疗后,没有患者出现放射性脑实质改变或临床恶化。
这些初步结果支持在治疗海绵状畸形时增加靶体积同时降低辐射剂量的策略。我们进一步建议纳入敏感性分析以评估结果的稳健性,特别是在海绵状畸形发病时间存在不确定性的情况下。